Aftermarket plates (biqu, Darkmoon)

I’m looking for a new plate for my H2S. I currently have the stock textured plate, the Bambu smooth plate, and a cheap smooth plate from AliExpress.

Basically, out of the Biqu Glacier, Darkmoon CFX Carbon Fiber, and Darkmoon G10 garolite plate which is “best”. By best I mean has both great adhesion and release of mostly PLA, PETG, TPU, ASA, and Biqu’s PLA-HR.

I had a WhamBam carbon fiber plate for my A1 and it was amazing but they haven’t released one for the H2 series yet.

Anyone know how much/visible the “light” carbon fiber texture is on the CFX? I print a lot of lithophanes and light boxes and would obviously prefer there to be no texture.

I have to imagine, I could probably get any of the plates and be perfectly happy, but because Audhd I have to get all the information I absolutely don’t need to make sure I’m getting the best of something I absolutely don’t need/won’t use to the full extent (like my H2S).

My main concern is will PLA-HR ruin the CFX or G10 plate or will the CFX plate leave too much of a texture for light based prints? I’ve had 2 glacier plates, the first one I ruined because I couldn’t get petg to release…at all. And the second one i used three times on my A1 to print various basketballs out of PLA-HR and it worked well.

I vastly prefer smooth plates because I hate having a texture on my prints, but my previous experience with the amazing adhesion of CF plates makes me lean that way.

Which one is best really depends on your priorities. Almost all CFX plates require some form of adhesive, no matter what the manufacturer claims.

I personally use a Darkmoon CFX on my H2D and a WhamBam CFX on my X1C. Both give excellent adhesion and clean release once you apply the right adhesive layer (I use Magigoo Original for most filaments).

PLA, including PLA-HR, won’t damage a CFX or G10 plate as long as you avoid printing directly on a bare surface without adhesive. The real risk isn’t from the material itself, but from excessive grip — especially with PLA or PETG when the plate is cold — which can tear the coating if you forcefully remove a print.

If you print a lot of light-based models like lithophanes, the CFX “light” texture is subtle but still visible under strong backlighting. In that case, a smooth plate with Magigoo might serve you better for aesthetic consistency.

While it would be a lie for me to say I NEVER used some sort of adhesion promoter on the WhamBam CFX on the A1, I would categorize it as close to never without actually being never with zero issues.

Basically what I’m hearing is I should get the Darkmoon CFX AND G10…