Are they really that bad?

I painted a dragon for hours — proper shading, weathering, the whole nine yards — and after 3 days: 0 downloads. Zero. No comments, no likes. Weird, right?

Full disclosure: the base model was AI-generated. I only trimmed, assembled, fixed prints, and painted it by hand. So it’s a collab between me and a neural net. Still — nobody even looked?

Anyone got quick tips to make AI-assisted models more appealing? Thumbnails, titles, descriptions, tags, or should I hide/announce the AI part differently? Roast the dragon, then help me fix it. :wink:

It looks like another generated model, and don’t take me wrong. I am not saying it’s bad. The main problem, from what i see, is that the model is a bit deceiving by showing it already painted. Also, the rules state that the profile should be inline with the model and in this case the model pictures are with color. The profile is not.

Other than than, i think that many people can see already if a model is AI generated or not and ignore them more than before.

That and the fact that there are thousands of dragons and other figurines that are similar and users usually pick the ones with more downloads. At least that is what i think.

Try and create a profile with it already painted so that users can print it with color. Also post a picture of it as it is, without color, to the profile since it’s not within the rules and it may even bring more people to print it since it shows the actual model (uncolored).

Give it some time. Makerworld is so full of stuff that it’s getting harder and harder to be noticed.

8 Likes

Thanks for the reply. Yeah, I know — it’s full of dragons, it’s one of the top tags on the “content creator” page. Thanks for the tip about the print profile; I thought I’d uploaded the unpainted image but I must’ve missed it.
I’m not sure how much a caption on the photo would help…
About skipping AI-made models, I think that’s a thing too, but at least here I’m showing an actual function — it’s a real, working cup holder.

1 Like

Part of the problem is probably that if you put a standard straight edged cup on it like most people have it’s not going to fit. The base area just isn’t big enough for a regular cup!

1 Like

Don’t use them.

AI models are not designed to be printed structurally, and they are not designed to be easily coloured.

Learn some CAD or modelling (think sculpt rather than construction). I know it isn’t easy and not for everyone, but a compromise is a compromise.

The joy of learning, developing your skills and sharing it with the world is immense.

3 Likes

I opened it and it is a good file, when you paint it there’s no to little contamination. so joint’s lines are straight? you deserve a boost just for this :man_shrugging: this is surely feasible multi color with little to no effort in painting, gz.

The little dragon is cute, but it’s a bit too flashy and catchy :melting_face:

2 Likes

I know, but i don’t want to make it tooo big. For this reason, on the print profile there’s a plate where in the middle I added a negative cilinder to fit the space of the regular cup

I’m able (not a master) to use fusion 360, if you chck my profile I made lot of model with it. The organic sculpiting isn’t for me.. I try.. but trust me, better if I stay away from it XD

For the point “AI models are not designed to be printed structurally, and they are not designed to be easily coloured.”
What you mean? offcourse I edit the model to made it simper to be printed, and with no ton of support and similar

thanks for your answer. How to improve it more?

Do things for yourself, they should please you, not strangers.

6 Likes

I will not discuss the design itself, as it is a matter of personal taste. However, the issue visible in the photo is that the shading is not properly rendered. This is a mistake many photography or image beginners make. They use lighting that is too bright or too much in an attempt to make every part appear bright, clear, and perfect. Dark areas are essential to show the model’s three-dimensionality, and this can only be achieved by illuminating it from the side. It is necessary to use shading to properly express the curves of the model. Furthermore, context is required for high download rates. What is the reason for including a dragon in that model? Do existing coasters evoke the image of a dragon? This model will only appeal to dragon enthusiasts. For high download rates, the model must include a context that resonates with a wide audience.

Yeah, don’t use Ai. That’s a start.

1 Like

yeah, in fact I like this model and this is the reason cos I made it :smiley: Now is here on my desk

Thank you for your time.
About the render.. this are real photo, not a render.. but yes, I use a top light (I put it on the kitchen :slight_smile: ) I will try to make a photo box for better result.
About of the contex, dragon don’t need context :smiley: We need more and more dragon in our life (offcourse is only a extetical model)

we walk on giants shoulder, do you know?

I’ll put it bluntly: The cover is just misleading. That’s not what you get, and most people just keep scrolling right past it. People want to know what it looks like straight out of the 3D printer, not what it might look like after it’s been painted.

AI certainly plays a role in that - it’s obvious - but many of the people this is presumably meant to appeal to overlook that fact. However, what they do notice is that you’re promoting it as ‘multicolour’, which it isn’t. Only when scrolling through the post it becomes apparent that you’ve painted it.

Paint and cup coaster are a terrible combination! Above all, a special coating must be applied to make it scratch-resistant.


What’s more, most people don’t just want one coaster - they want at least four - and they want them to be stackable. Your main problem: Your 3D print is too impractical to be a coaster, but it’s not distinctive enough to serve as a decoration either. It’s neither one thing nor the other.

On top of that, there are already hundreds of thousands of them in both categories. The reason you don’t have any download counts is probably because MakerWorld AI doesn’t know how to categorise you – you used tags that don’t really fit.

Anyone looking for decorations for their “dungeon” will click right past yours. The same goes for someone looking for “tea”. I guess the AI is trying to stick you in every possible category, and constantly notice that something just doesn’t fit here.


Without meaning to sound critical - it’s just my personal opinion - but when I look at your profile, you’re literally flooding MakerWorld with fake covers and AI-generated stuff. That’s just not sustainable. Sure, you’ve racked up your points. But if you’d just uploaded ten decent models during that time, you’d easily have ten times as many points.


Even though you’re using AI, with the sheer volume of 3D models you’re cranking out, you end up with more work than if you just sat down and put some thought into it.

Or to put it simply: I don’t see that you’ve developed the basic skills needed to set yourself apart from AI or to refine it in a way. You’ve been replaced by AI that you use yourself, because now anyone can do what you can do through the MakerWorld website.


Solution: Learn CAD or Blender and at least tweak your AI models a bit to fix the most obvious mistakes. Your dragon has a few flaws, but I’d better not get into that now - my post is already too long.


Edit: By the way, regarding your second model: It’s a really stupid idea to use PLA for hot drinks. PLA isn’t food-safe to begin with, and then pouring boiling water on it? You really should look into this whole topic of 3d printing. Making such a beginner’s mistake after all this time is really not good. People who don’t know any better will end up drinking that crap- in other words, dissolved plastic. Even though PLA doesn’t melt until it reaches higher temperatures, particles can dissolve even in just very hot water.

Even if you write a warning under it a hundred times, people will just think you’re nuts. Especially considering that you posted this in a contest where food safety is actually a requirement.

You should count yourself lucky they haven’t kicked you out yet for that clear violation of the rules.

5 Likes

One can create organic shapes in Fusion.

Ok listen, people are unpractical (to be very gentle while saying it)

You can improve it painting it on the slicer, that’s what I would do.

Note that if I have to paint with acrylics I do print stuff with RESIN PRINTER, not fdm.

If i print with the H2D I PRETEND to print it coloured and not paint it later.

Voilà

I’m posting this as a separate comment: In fact, all three designs violate the rules. That said, two of them aren’t that big of a deal - they just don’t fit the “cup holder” theme. The third one definitely violates the rules, as mentioned in my previous comment, because it isn’t food-safe, which is a basic requirement.

You haven’t even read through what this is all about… that’s the root of the problem - it’s why nobody is downloading it. Even if you get downloads and points when someone reports it, all three of your designs will be removed, along points - and rightly so.

Please don’t take this as harsh criticism, but come on, you haven’t even read the rules…

3 Likes

The infuser seems perfect to me. What could be better than a cool skull guiding you through oncology… :skull:

3 Likes