Analysis of BambuLab’s Security Update
Background
BambuLab has recently announced a security update for its 3D printers, focusing on the use of MQTT (Message Queuing Telemetry Transport) and integration with home automation systems like Node-RED, Home Assistant, and ioBroker and others. This update aims to enhance device security and minimize potential risks.
MQTT and Security Concerns
-
MQTT: This protocol, developed in 1999, is known for its lightness and efficiency, but it lacks built-in security features. Data is transmitted in plaintext, with no encryption in transit or end-to-end encryption. MQTT was originally designed for simple applications like turning lights on and off or controlling window shades, not for controlling complex devices like 3D printers.
-
Security Risks: Controlling 3D printers via MQTT can be problematic, as data outside a secure TLS tunnel is vulnerable to manipulation. This could lead to data leaks (e.g., theft of 3D models), printer manipulation, or even physical hazards like fires.
BambuLab Connect App
- Function: The BambuLab Connect app allows third-party applications to securely upload sliced print data to the printers. Orca Slicer can pass the data to Bambu Connect, which then establishes a secure channel to the printer. This app also offers enhanced notification features, such as webcam images of print results.
Liability and Security Responsibility
- Liability: The question of who is responsible for security incidents remains open. Is it the user, BambuLab, or a third-party provider like RandomApp42? The introduction of BambuLab’s security update is a step in the right direction to minimize these risks, even if the communication of the changes was suboptimal.
Community Reactions
- Josef Prusa: The reaction of Josef Prusa, a competitor in the 3D printing market, is shortsighted. Prusa could benefit from such security measures, as his printers are also vulnerable to similar security gaps. It is speculated that Prusa might introduce similar security measures within the next 12 months, if his ego allows it.
Conclusion
BambuLab’s security update is a necessary measure to address the risks associated with using MQTT for controlling 3D printers. It ensures that critical operations are authorized and securely executed, thereby increasing the integrity and security of the printers. The introduction of Bambu Connect as a secure interface for third-party software shows that BambuLab is seeking a balance between security and user-friendliness. However, the communication of these changes could be improved to alleviate user concerns and clearly convey the benefits of the new security measures.