I tested this with my machine today. Using precision wall+arachne, without hole/contour compensation enabled. My machine has been calibrated with vision encoder.
Note that I’m printing in Bambu PLA Basic, but since no compensation is turned on, so no scaling would be applied.
2mm hole: I got 1.85mm
3mm hole: I got 2.88-2.90mm
4mm hole: I got 3.93mm
All measured by using a mitutoyo caliper.
So does this make sense? I think yes, a Δd=0.1mm ish error is well expected. It’s just how slicer works for FDM, as it’s already below 1/4 of my linewidth.
Now, with using Classic wall generator, also without precision wall turned on:
2mm hole: I got 1.6mm
3mm hole: I got 2.67mm
4mm hole: I got 3.7mm
This is again well expected. The 0.3mm-0.4mm range of error is basically the width of 1-2x half width of a line.
You can’t expect a 0.4mm nozzle to have sub 0.1mm level of accuracy anywhere, it’s just not physically possible. Round holes are just exposing it better than most of other shapes.