How do I set a different license for certain countries?

MakerWorld does not seem to allow you to choose different licenses to different regions.

Say country X is being mean to us so I want to make my model free everywhere but country X has to pay money, or perhaps they can’t use it at all. How do I do this?

edit: I also want a way to restrict use e.g. “not to be used for war” etc.

You can’t.

Also - there’s a quote from Game of Thrones:

The common people pray for rain, healthy children, and a summer that never ends. It is no matter to them if the high lords play their game of thrones, so long as they are left in peace. They never are.

Country X isn’t being mean to you - it’s Country X “high lords” playing game of thrones with “high lords” of your country. The normal people are… Normal. Limiting licence just because the people are in country X is kinda discriminatory. And if the people from country X are actually mean to you, just say something like “designed in country Y by proud citizen of Y” and those from X that don’t like Y will avoid it like a plague :wink:

4 Likes

This does not apply to democracies which can choose their leader. If the leader is being naugty, it’s because the majority of the population wanted it.

I think the “solution” is to put a restrictive license in the model’s profile, and then provide a list of less restrictive, conditional licenses in the text.

That’s pretty much victim blaming. The only people running for office are people who should not be in power and people are choosing lesser evil (but that still leaves them with evil). If you restricted your models because of government of a country, what is a citizen supposed to do when they didn’t vote for them?

Also your “majory wanted it” argument is flawed.
For example in Poland, there’s 37 miillion people, allowed to vote in 2023 were 29.5 million, out of that actually voted 21 million and out of that for the current prime minister party only voted 6.2million. So that’s 16.7% of citizens, certainly not majority… For current government coallition - that’s still just 25% of population…

3 Likes

just set the license as restricted and then host the file on another site (such as your own) with your custom one.

but its cute that you think it’d do anything since enforcing it would require you to go to that other country and hire a lawyer and bring it to court.

1 Like

You can’t without a custom solution.
A non-expert viewpoint:

  • Practically, publishing a model on an internet cross-border platform makes it hard to enforce geographic licences.
  • I am unaware of which licence types you are aiming for, but if open licence types, recheck if geographic licence restrictions are allowed, or you may violate the licence.
1 Like

Also, VPN’s exist and would circumvent any regional paywalling someone tried to do

1 Like

Your point about needing to go to court or hire a lawyer in another country is valid. Many digital rights management (DRM) protections and licenses can be bypassed if someone really wants to break the rules, and that’s where legal action or international cooperation would come into play.

Well, in general you don’t, licensing on MW follows an international structure. You would have to post it separately, using your own licensing agreement and/or geofencing.