EXACTLY this, so many images of an AI generated model, but no actual printed result, to show the image can print! That is who Makerworld are finally targeting. YES, I use AI for generating things, but I actually try to print them and IF they work I will upload them with actual images. As I said in the All AI images must go thread, that led to this one. A lot of “users” upload AI images, get the points, buy a printer, then sell it. Keep repeating that, and never print an actual model. So hopefully, this will deal with that.
The BEST thing (for me anyway), this is not a total ban. I can still use the AI to generate an idea, use Aimia, to model and colour it, and then Meshmixer to correct it, and adjust it, so it is printable, then print it out, then take images etc.
One question though. IF I was to upload images of the printed out model in 3 or 4 different angles, upload the STL AND 3MF files, but then proceeded to upload an image of the 3mf model not printed would this be allowed? It shows a 3D multicolour print, but not the real image, just the modelled one??
Don’t overthink it. The main point is simply that the cover shouldn’t be misleading and should somehow show the actual print.
How you approach that is entirely up to you.
You don’t need to, since that’s not part of the new rule anyway. You don’t need to worry about whether every possible combination is shown or not, just whether what you’re displaying is misleading.
I had a look at your profile, and all your cover photos are real, so this doesn’t affect you:
The rule says you have to show the complete model on the cover. and “match the model files” , and “accurately reflect the finished 3D print”. But Many of those 3mf files have far more in them than the cover photo shows by itself.
Fully agree I’m not trying to mislead, and the text (should anybody bother to actually read it), explains it all. But there’s often more options available in the .3mf files than is represented in the pictures.
Sadly, it feels to me like they put some of the burden onto those of us not using any AI pictures, instead of simply getting rid of the AI pictures.
Once again: Those rules don’t apply to you as you think.
If anyone’s unaffected by this, it’s you, with your 17 models whose galleries are practically overflowing with real photos - which, by the way, is actually pretty impressive.
Just ask yourself: What could be misleading about that? Nothing… exactly.
You are the perfect role model.
The system has even automatically recognized your photos as real.
If it is a typo, then it is not going to be worth of the effort to take and upload more photos. Many users don’t even read the description, let alone being bothered by a typo or two or three
If the edit will have a significant effect on the model then I would say it is worthwhile to take more photos. I keep each and every final version of the model that I printed, so if needed, it is minimal effort to take more photos. I don’t understand why some keep saying they would have to reprint the model to take more photos.
You have 30 days to replace that cover image with a photo of the printed dog bowl.
If you don’t have any photo of the printed dog bowl, you would need to take 4 photos (one for the cover image plus 3 additional photos from 3 different angles) when you go edit that upload.
The current cover image is not a photo but it can be used in one of the image slots after the real photos.
Without judging, just looking at it pragmatically and objectively, I think it’s also worth asking whether it’s really worth the effort in the case of the model used as an example, considering it only had 19 prints in total over two years.
I can only speak for myself, but if it were my own model, I’d consider it a failure and completely rethink the concept. In the sense of learning from it, doing better the second time around, and leaving the old model behind.
Finally, MW is listening on this much-needed update !
The only thing that I wish it were different is this part of the new rule “Models without a compliant cover image will be subject to reduced visibility.”
In my opinion, models without a complant cover should be assigned one by MW uisng the first real photo. This is easily doable since MW already requires 4 real photos. If the upload has none, then the upload should not be accepted at all.
By assigning the cover image when the uploader’s chosen cover is non-compliant, the uploader will know and the model will still receive the normal visibility. This will avoid having the question that some have raised: how does an uploader know if their cover image is non-compliant and their model is under restricted visibility?