Two retraction tests of PET-G

I printed two retraction tests with the same settings from PET-G, but with different models.


The first model is in Bambu Studio, the second is in Orca Slicer + Bambu Connect.

Settings for both models:

Speed:
Outer wall: 100

Temperature:
Bed: 60
Nozzle: First Layer - 240; Other Layers - 235

Fan:
Min fan speed threshold: 0/30
Maxn fan speed threshold: 10/10

Retraction:
Lenght: 3
Retraction speed: 45

The question is why the first model is of poor quality, and the second one tends to be better? Wiy is different quality for same settings?

BS model file - Retraction+test+x9.BS.3mf (364.1 KB)

OS model file -
retraction_tower_PETG_17m18s.gcode.3mf (76.7 KB)

Not sure how to interpret this but just based on the size of the two files, there is a lot going on with the Studio file (364 kb) compared to the Orca (77 kb)

This test for BS I downloaded from MakerWorld.
Test of Orca was in Orca - Calibration → Retraction test.

Those .3mf files from MakerWorld will import the settings from whoever uploaded the print to MakerWorld in addition to the model.
If Studio asks you if you want to import everything or just the geometry, I choose the geometry only.

Sometime it is very obvious because it may change your printer and build plate which you will get a message asking about which printer. Im not near my computer so can’t tell you the exact message but if the original uploader was using an X1C and a textured plate and you have a P1S and a smooth plate you have to correct that.
The problem is if the uploader has made settings changes that are on a different tab, you may not see those changes.
I do not know how that works on MakerWorld but I want the model ONLY. Not the settings the model uploader had in his printer.

First model is thin so It ooze or/and string at model.
Now I recalibrate temperature, speed, flow rate, flow dynamics and result is more better.

Well you know, I have to make that test better by checking and unchecking and fiddling with settings before I can determine if the print will be any good.
Like checking and changing purge tower settings on single color prints.