I get that a review on a profile shouldn’t work if you change the settings.
However, like I said, I’ve downloaded and printed straight from a number of properties and rating still isn’t an option.
I definitely get the frustration of people with little or now frustration thinking a model is bad because they didn’t slice it correctly (I’ve been sharing popular designs for almost a decade so had a few of these), but equally I think you should be able to rate the model itself.
I think you should be able to rate/review the design itself, and if you do print straight from an uploaded profile, apply to a rating of that too.
But the model, the design, that is the thing I care about. That is the thing that took the skill to produce.
Yes good slicin is important, but there are so many variables that affect it, down to even different manufacturers of the same filament type printing better with different temperatures or speeds.
Anyway, I am not able to rate anything I’ve printed regardless of whether I’ve printed directly from a profile on here, or sliced it myself, but I have received several ratings on profiles of my own designs in that time.