Why I don't like the Exclusive program at this moment

I had a few AI created items that all had their post processing in MeshMixer.
Every model I had on my profile had at least a few hours of work in MeshMixer before I really liked it, and before I posted it. Straight out of AI, models are almost never printable, and they don’t look good. I took my models and repaired them, added things, removed other things, made them stronger, made them printable without using supports, etc. Also, a lot of times I colored them in Bambu Studio, so there was a colored profile and a single color profile.

Also, every cover photo I posted was made with a pretty good quality photo, shot on a greenscreen and edited in Photoshop. Made of the correct dimensions and given i title in the photo, so I did a lot of work for it.

Yet, on 21 models, In a few months time, I never succeeded to get more than a thousend views, on my whole channel, and a maximum of 11 downloads in almost half a year.

I have seen a lot more succes on Thingiverse and Thangs, where I even sold more models then people downloaded for free from my channel here on makersworld, and I do blame that to visibility. I used the same pictures, the same tags, the same titles.

I now took down most of my models here, as they were partly AI content (with a lot of fixing and modeling afterwards), and a lot of people tell me that AI content, or even AI generated parts of the thumbnails can decrease the number of views on your channel.

I still don’t know if I will publish new things here or not. To be honest, for every post I used to be working about 15 to 25 minutes per post, generating the pictures, writing the text and tags, etc. and I just don’t see it work like I see on other model sharing sites.

Thanks again all for your thoughts. I appreciate it.

In my opinion, renders shouldn’t be allowed as cover photos. There should be no exceptions on this. Making exceptions to the photo requirement undermines the respect of this rule and all other rules set up by MW.

On which platform specifically that you have sold more models than the free downloads on MW? It that’s the case, we should all look into it. In my experience, sharing a model for free download is one thing, getting customers to open their wallets to buy it is a different and much harder ball game.

I disagree - there’s a valid case for posting models without print profiles. On print profiles it’s different matter and I do agree with them having to have real print photo.

Yes, I acknowledged that there are different views on the photo requirement.

The only reason that I can think of MW allowing renders is to make it easier and attractive for designers who don’t own BL printers to post their models here. But the rule is not applied evenly. Some have said their models got taken out because of the lack of real photos. ( I am aware of the possibility that some of those claims can be exaggerated or or completely false)

Either allow renders to be used for covers for alll users, or don’t allow any at all.
Given the choice, many designers (me not included :slight_smile: ) may skip the time-consuming process of fully testing and printing a model and instead choose to just make a design and post. The ability to skip the printing and photo-taking can be extremely attractive to designers churning out models en masse such as Hueforge users.

These renderings … I don’t know. Now I’m reflecting on my behaviour without having paid attention to it before.

I see models on a page and one caught my eye. Also how detailed it was. I had a look at it. But if I’m not sure I look for comments and see photos. Then I look at the photos.

So I also unconsciously make sure I see what I’m getting.

As you get more and more into photography, these photographs get better. And you get pretty good results in a short space of time. Creating something that then looks terrible in print is not my thing. I have no desire to do that. I want to hold my cool model in my own hands and be proud to show it to others.

Do what works for you. It’s exactly right. Everyone here does what works for them. Thank you for your insights and the sharing of your experience!

I made all my content private, and step away from makerworld. This will give me more peace of mind and get me less frustrated.

Again thanks for all your valuable information and thoughts, it’s much appreciated.

I’m fairly new to actually uploading to MakerWorld, But i’ve lurked it to download stuff for about 6 months.

it’s definitely giving more weight to people spamming uploads and profiles, I’ve noticed a vast change this last week with medium and large creators here spitting out their latest creations across multiple pages instead of in the one.

it feels like this is just a step back in the direction before the point overhaul (pre-boost) where quantity over quality was king, get your gift cards, and move on

Regardless of what side of this you’re on, it makes a world of difference.

I went private, then deleted most of mine. Let’s face it, they weren’t original so I can take my lumps. Still feel better, much better now that I’m off MakerWorld. I put them up on MakerOnilne just to earn enough to support my resin printer. No cares at all what they do, cause resin isn’t expensive.

I let it get to me. I shouldn’t have. I feel immature and ashamed of the anger and stress this whole thing caused within me. Now I just enjoy my coffee and move on.

Social media is hard on people. Twitter, facebook, and others just propagate bad manners, snarky comments, and frustration these days. Too many feel like they don’t get ahead without pushing other people down. That spills over into other boards. It’s wildly disruptive.

Crud happens. I wouldn’t worry too much about it. And taking a break sure clears the head. The other thing is just don’t engage the ones who frustrate you the most. They aren’t worth the distress they cause. And trolls are the worst. They seem to thrive on negative emotions and seeing what they can stir up. Engaging them can be fun for a while but gets too draining. They aren’t interested in actual exchanges and sharing knowledge. They just want to disrupt. It’s their oxygen.

Despite the higher visibility of exclusive models I keep my models not exclusive and I got huge popularity boost in recent weeks. My not exclusive models are sometimes visible when I scroll front page and hashtags. I’m new maker who started uploading 2 months ago and I don’t feel like new users are limited in any way. As a new user I gathered over 6000 points with about 40 models uploaded. Some of my models have only a few downloads, but another ones are still being downloaded even 2 months later generating a passive points income.

I am not sure this is true at the moment. Maybe someone can find out by picking a model and comparing the impressions the model got before and after entering the program. But the way it is now almost any model can get in. The model probably doesn’t even have to be exclusive to get in because no criteria check is in place.

Stop using spectacular ultra-distracting backgrounds in your cover images

Do you really think that this is a reason?
I will try it out, and see if that changes anything.
Thanks.

A random uptick in popularity is typically when a model is featured by MakerWorld. Is that what you are referring to? Featured models always stand out, whether exclusive or not.

AI models are well received on makerworld itself, lots have plenty of downloads and likes that dwarf the comments here, it’s just not well received by a minority being which are some of the frequent posters on this forum. If yours are not popular then there’s something affecting it, not the fact that it’s AI.

The more “AI models”, to put it simply, are published, the more points they receive from the large pot available on Makerworld. This could in turn lead, as in the past, to a general reduction in points or the introduction of stricter upper limits for the acquisition of points. Models that have been made with real effort - I now refer to these models as “handmade” to make a clear distinction - will become more valuable. This in turn could lead to such handmade models only being available to a limited extent or even disappearing completely one day as free models and only being available for a fee. The trend towards paying for models has been around for some time. But it could become even more pronounced.

Best regards!

This is imho a typical problem: “how to take a stone out from a lake once thrown in”. Or, in other words, generally speaking, “how to make models lacking any interesting features to be mass downloaded”.
Such problems can be easily raised by anyone, but cannot be solved by the summ of the brightest minds available anyware, mainly because there are no decent solutions, nor magic tricks, whatever is the algorithm used by MW to show models.

There is a single answer for the problem raised here: the interesting, good quality models will get attraction, the other models will be just useful for comparison. Playing fair, the success comes only with great imagination and hard work. Playing unfair… well, this is a different topic :slight_smile:

This… I totally understand what you are saying, yet I hate it that you are saying this, in regards to my AI models.
I used AI for some of my models, I used a generator (Hyperhuman) that costs me about 340 dollars for a year of usage, and the models it generates are NOT usable for direct printing. I then do about 2 to 4 hours of work in Meshmixer, before they are printable, but even more important, before I like them. Now… We can argue about the usage of the word HANDMADE, but we can certainly not argue about the word EFFORT, while reading all the reactions on my post here, I am being criticized for putting LOW QUALITY models on MakersWorld.

Now, to be totally clear, Non of my models are low quality. I can assure you, and everyone else, that my models are very well printable, they don’t suffer from any of the problems that most AI designs have, etc. They are made nicer then the AI generator was possible to make them, because I spent time and effort into my models. Yet, this post is about them not being SEEN, not about them not being liked or printed. People can’t like or print a model that they do not see. People can’t judge my models as being Low Quality, or Made without effort, if they don’t see my models.

I am sorry, but this is really making me very sad. I am constantly being accused of things which are not the point of this post. Judge me on my models AFTER you have seen of printed them, but don’t judge me because of the word AI generated, without knowing my models.

Oh, and by the way. People that gave me tips about my model pictures, keywords to use, the use of a higher quality camera, etc. This is very well received and I thank you for your tips and explenations.

It’s not referring to your models, I don’t know your models. It is generally valid. But what I said also includes models that originate from some generator (Make my vase etc.).