X2D vs P2S level of complexity

You can also just remove the feet which are very soft rubber and do whatever brackets, or just lay it on the belly. Maybe not bad to put some anti slip tape on the bottom. Original feet are very spft and it has a lot of jerk around while printing.

If the feet slide, I’ll use some anti-slip silicone stickers—probably the simplest and most effective solution. I still need to make up my mind about the printer though :rofl:

Feet should not slide they are very soft. But because of that there are lots of jerk, so for tight spaces and not very solid places better without them just anti slip tape.

Thanks for the suggestion. I’ve made space in the stereo cabinet (poor stereo :rofl:) and I’ll figure out the best solution to implement once the printer arrives. Right now, I’m just really confused and uncertain about which printer to get. The X2D, like the Sirens calling Ulysses, is calling out to me—she’s a tempter… making me promises. The price holds me back and I tell myself, “well, I’ll just get the printer and do multicolor with the A1 mini,” then I think, what if I want to do multicolor on a larger surface, how do I do that? And then I need a dryer,the AMS could help me out with that. So I tell myself I’ll make a big effort and get it with the AMS, but at that point, I don’t need the A1 mini anymore. And what if I sell it and I’m not able to manage the X2D? Then I tell myself, “go with a more relaxed choice and get the P2S,” you spend less and get the AMS, so there’s no need to sell the A1 Mini. But then you can’t print (or rather, with a bit more difficulty) ABS and ASA, and even though that’s not my main goal, I’d like to try these materials… and so on :rofl: Enough. I’m not thinking about it anymore. This weekend I’m pressing the button and whatever happens, happens. When the head doesn’t help, you go with the heart. Even if you make a mistake, it’s easier to forgive ourselves.

I’d verify you can remove the feet. I read somewhere that the soft feet are intentional and designed to absorb some of the forces imposed on the machine by it’s fast movements. This makes logical sense from an engineering perspective.

Thanks for the tips! First, I saw Bambu Studio had an update that included some changes that looked like they might have been intended to fix the ironing issue so I installed that. Then, I did the manual flow dynamics and flow rate calibrations you mentioned. When I look at the filament settings my flow ratio is 0.98 (seeing yours is 1.0395 makes me question this). Not sure where to find the flow dynamics but best result from my calibration was 1.018. Once I did that, I ran one of the Ironing calibration models from makers world and my best results were in between 20mm / 20% and 25mm / 25% so I split it at 22mm @ 22%. I also selected the options from the new update that dealt with surface finishes. Sub-top suface pattern= monotonic and ironing pattern set to Archimedean Chords. Now armed with my new settings, I printed a model that I’d done before that had a rough finish and… it was actually worse lol. :man_facepalming:
What sucks is I’m a new user and just don’t have the experience to troubleshoot this effectively and really, I feel like I shouldn’t have to, especially when an entry level printer like the A1 isn’t having this problem. I’ve spent days worth of hours on this and at least a spool of filament if not two and I’m no closer to a quality print. I’ve essentially spent $900 for a printer and AMS that only works for things that don’t need a nice finish. That’s a bitter pill…

Let me throw out the obvious question:

Could it be that your device is actually faulty and that this has nothing to do with the settings at all? If that’s the case, you might want to contact Bambu Support ASAP. Just a thought, before the warranty expires.

After calibration, the print quality should definitely not look worse.

Yea, that’s starting to cross my mind. Others seem to have the same issue so maybe they’ve identified the problem. I’m just not relishing that process lol.

Of course you can remove them as they are removeable :smiley: . And of course there is engineering reasons for them to be soft, and most probably Bambu will not be very happy about that. But the engineering reason is very obvious, the same as slapping and grinding PTFE tubes and many other “engineering and design choices” they have made. Most probably to bring production cost below the sanitary minimum… Same feet on the early models like X1 are not so soft - FYI.

You can see in other topics for H line even the holder for the feet inside the body of the printer develop cracks and could broke. In other topics you can see because of the swing and jerk printer moves and AMS can fly away. For example mine was impossible to be used on relatively stable kitchen table. And even set on the solid concrete floor with tiles, it was moving constantly mm by mm in some direction. And this whole inertia in the body have no way to not affect bigger/heavy prints, as the whole bed is shaking around. So this is what it is - cheap printer. A mini is much cheaper and has no swing at all. Works absolutely fine on the same table X2D is trying to jump from :smiley: . And I see no meaningful difference in the speed. Most people say no issues with X2D and all cool by default, and this seems to be true until they try to print something bigger and more flatter, then we got the topics for under extrusion, warping and so on.

And of course there could be range of defective printers out there, but how one could verify this out of the box? As if the printer does not want to print, scratch the bed, do not extrude and so on it is kind of obvious. But If you get only defects here and there, one print is good other is not, and only ironing does not work and stuff like this how you can figure this out? I think this is where community could be very helpful - but not with defaults like - you are doing something wrong mine is fine, and call bambu.

Yea, she does buck a lot with the soft feet. I swear I heard my AMS yell “YEEE HAAAAW!” the other day lol.