99% off coupon maths seems wonky?

Hi all! I recently used some of my makerworld points to get a “99% off coupon” for the LED Lamp Kit 001. This is the first time I have done this, so I was curious how it all worked. I was surprised to see the dollar values that it produced, which didn’t feel like 99% off to me. So I grabbed my calculator to double check, and sure enough, it doesn’t seem to be.

The kit cost $20, at full price. 1% of this is $0.20, twenty cents. That is what I expected to pay, with local tax (10% GST, in Australia) added. That should have made it $0.22. Shipping was added extra, $8 which is OK, I guess. But the price I was given was $1.19 (before shipping). This looks to me closer to 90% off, not 99%. Am I right or am I missing something?

Do I really care about the $1 or so difference here? No, not really. What bothers me is that this is just wrong. At best it is a mistake, at worst it is theft. In Australia, such things can attract a sizable fine if not corrected and compensation given. Bambu Labs are potentially in trouble here. It might seem trivial, but anything involving money is potentially pretty serious.

What do you think about this?

1 Like

So, I went back to my confirmation email to see if this would shed any light on this discount. If anything, it is even worse. We have a 10% tax, called “GST” in Australia. I have no idea how they can come up with $0.84 tax, and it doesn’t even seem to be included the total? Oh my. Can someone explain this to me, because I really do not understand it.

Here is what I think it should be – $20 price is discounted 99% to $0.20. Shipping is $8, so a total of $8.20. GST is 10%, and yes it can go on shipping, so that is adding $0.82. The grand total should be $9.02. Pretty close, actually, to what I was charged ($9.19), but still not right. So the numbers Bambu Labs show are really hard to explain. I am the first to admit I don’t get it.

If the taxes are in the subtotal, which they appear to be, then the cost of the kit is now $0.35. This is close to the $0.20 but still isn’t right. Anyone?

My assumption is, they apply the 99% to the net value of the item but keep the taxes as if the net value is undiscounted. Then they use the discounted net value + original tax value as the new net item value.

2 Likes

The original tax would have been $2, so I’m not sure that is the answer.

true, not sure how my math was supposed to work out. But I know companies like to handle it that way, so maybe it is part of the solution.

BL did something similar with their boost tokens which they advertise as $1 in gift cards but it is actually ~$0.89. When you look into the fine print they say its a $1 equivalent minus taxes.

1 Like

I think they just calculated the coupon wrong. The coupon deducts 18,81$ – so whoever created it in Shopify probably thought that the kit’s original price was 19,00$. If you care, you should open a ticket with them.

4 Likes

No - prices in AUS always include the GST when displayed.

The GST was $1.81, and the raw price of the item is $18.18.

Having said that, I still don’t know how they worked out the figures. There seems to be some serious rounding issues in the invoices.

1 Like

hho, I think you are right. Thank you for suggesting to open a ticket, I will do that. Cheers.

Edit : I have now submitted a general ticket. We shall see what come of it.

Sorry this is somewhat unrelated but I was wondering about people’s opinion.

I know even with this error it’s still only $9.19; but do you guys recommend getting these kits?
I like the idea of making remixes of them but also I’m aware that some of them have very little electronics, which makes me question the value of buying them directly. the also just remind me of the crunch labs type of kit in general (which are for kids).

@CianosGeos Well, yes, this is quite a different subject so I suggest you start a new thread for it. On saying that, I don’t know, this is my first one and I just got it the mail earlier today. I’m looking forward to playing with it, so in terms of entertainment value per dollar, I think it is probably a good investment?

1 Like

What happend? Did they answer?

I just had a look to the points shop and with points its even more strange.

The Maker’s Essential Kit A

would be interesting for 99% off.

In the EU - Shop the price is 156 EUR


When 524 Points relates to 40 EUR,
then 156 EUR should be 2044 Points.

So why is the price 1391 Points in the points shop?

Okay, maybe they give a discount of 32% for buyers in the point shop!?

156EUR => 2044 Points
2044 Points * 0,68 = 1390 (rounded) and on for the fun = 1391

(Maybe)

But 99% off means that you have to pay 1% of it.

So 1391 Point * 0.01 = 14 Points

or

2044 Point * 0.01 = 21 Points

I don’t get it.

Probably because the real cost of the parts in that box doesn’t align with the regular gift card exchange rate, so they offer a slight discount if you exchange for the coupon.

Yes, I added that idea also while you added your comment.
But the 99% stuff is strange.

BBL here is a suggestion: Make clear what the original price (points) is.
And what the reduced one:

@xiaoxiniu maybe you can help with a clearification here, too?