Actions taken against spamming of low-quality models on MakerWorld

我完全支持拓竹减少垃圾文件提升模型质量的想法,但是我认为目前的做法是盲目且粗鲁的。
I fully support Bambu’s idea of reducing junk files and improving model quality, but I think the current approach is blind and rude.

一个作品是否优秀不应该简单的依靠是否没有实物图来评判。有很多原因可能导致作者只使用渲染图,比如可以获得一个整洁美观的背景以更好的展示作品(有多少人希望乱糟糟的背景比自己的作品更抢镜?)可以有更加适合作品的场景,,可以避免不必要的重复工作和资源浪费,可以更快速的体现创意上传分享等等。
The quality of a work should not be judged simply by the absence of a physical image. There are many reasons why an author might want to use only renderings, such as to get a clean and beautiful background to better display the work (how many people want a messy background to be more photostealer than their own work?). It can have a more suitable scene for the work, can avoid unnecessary duplication of work and waste of resources, can reflect the creativity faster and so on.

真正需要惩罚的是恶意利用规则获利的人,而现在的方案同样会被人利用来攻击优秀的创作者,在惩罚投机者的同时也在误伤优秀的创作者。
What really needs to be punished is those who maliciously use the rules to profit, and the current scheme will also be used by people to attack good creators, punishing speculators at the same time, but also hurt good creators.

我确信目前的做法同时伤害了许多作者的优秀作品这是违背初衷的。他们理应得到补偿。
I am convinced that the current approach also hurts the good work of many authors. It defeats the purpose, and they deserve to be compensated.

目前的行为还存在以下几点问题
There are several problems with the current approach

1.没有有效的通知:不是所有作者善于使用论坛(就像我)官方因该通过多种途径告知作者规则的变动,直至模型被举报下架前我也没收到任何来自系统的提示获知新的准则。

  1. No effective notification: Not all authors are good at using forums (like me) Bambu should inform authors of rule changes in a variety of ways, and I didn’t receive any alerts from the system about the new guidelines until the model was reported to be taken down.

2.简单盲目的评判标准:只依靠是否存在实物图作为评判标准,可以轻松的被人恶意使用,伤害到那些毫不知情的优秀创作者。
2. Simple and blind judging criteria: relying only on whether there is a physical drawing as a judging criterion can be easily used by people maliciously, hurting those excellent creators who are unaware of it.

3.不能解根本决低质量模型的问题:上传低质量模型的用户仍然可以随便拍几张照片上传低质量模型,只不过让人恶心的更真实罢了!
3. Can not fundamentally solve the problem of low-quality models: users who upload low-quality models can still take a few photos to upload low-quality models, which will only make people more disgusting!

2 Likes