Best Filament for p1s

In no particular order:

  1. PETG – Every spool I tested under $15 on Amazon worked fine. Brands tested (in no order): 3DJoHor, ELEGOO Rapid PETG, and CC3D PETG (same factory as HZST3D).

  2. Polycarbonate – Only used CC3D, also sold under HZST3D.

  3. PLA – Everything above, plus Jayo (AKA Sunlu), though it’s now priced out of the under-$14/spool market. See my post: So you think your high-priced fancy-schmancy filament is the best?

  4. TPU – Tested three brands; only ERYONE made the cut, but it’s still overpriced at $14 for 0.5kg.

That’s not part of my testing criteria, and I don’t own an AMS. I primarily print functional parts. Truth be told, I don’t think much of Bambu Filament—overpriced, poor customer service, bad shipping terms, and a nonexistent return policy. Early on, when testing a new filament every two weeks, I returned about 1 in 10 spools to Amazon, even after using 30% for calibration. No questions asked. That kind of service—along with 1-day to same-day shipping—is something Bambu can’t even dream of matching.

That’s debatable. By my standards, even Bambu filament doesn’t print well without tuning—but I’m picky. :man_shrugging::smirk:

I have a modified P1P with a printed pegboard enclosure. One benefit of mastering filament calibration is knowing which filaments print best on which surfaces. For example, for PETG, I use my engineering plate with a Kapton overlay. See this post on Gizmo Dorks Kapton Sheets.

Then I may not have much to offer you because price is my first criteria. But consider this—if you could get 1-2 spools free for every two you buy, just by fine-tuning and building a filament library, would that interest you? I don’t mind paying when I get my money’s worth. What I can’t stand is buyer’s remorse—overpaying for an inferior product with bad service. That’s Bambu Filament in a nutshell in my experience, and I have enough posts here showing the results of untuned Bambu Filament.

The only time I bought Bambu Filament after my initial P1P purchase was when they forced me to. Early on, they routinely ran out of Basic PLA, and I had to turn to Amazon just to get Black PLA to finish my P1P Pegboard case. But in hindsight, Bambu actually did me a favor. By pushing me onto the open market—something I likely wouldn’t have risked otherwise—they made me realize that filament is filament. Once you master calibration, almost all of them perform well. I will give a nod to their PETG HF, though—it prints almost as flawlessly as PLA-CF, which in my experience holds the record for “perfect” print quality with minimal tuning.

** Edit and disclaimer: I want to make one disclaimer: I know that I have definitely not exhausted all filament tuning options—just the high-level ones like temperature, flow ratio, PA, and max flow rate. There are many more parameters, such as first-layer speed, that can make the difference between a successful profile and a failed one.

As an example, I had a failed print overnight, which turned out to be due to not using a clean plate. However, I also discovered that adjusting the first-layer print speed improved adhesion. This was a first for me, as it wasn’t a parameter I had previously experimented with. It also makes me wonder if some of the filaments I returned to Amazon might have performed better now that I have more experience. Proof that one should never stop learning, this is what science is all about. :smirk:

Can you provide the settings for your Sunlu? I have 4 spools of black that I have projects(printing AMS risers, and BTT config things I would like to use this filament for. Plus my wife wants things, lol

In the latest version of Bambu Studio there should be profiles for Sunlu filaments…

I see a lot of brands are using cardboard reels which I have heard cause issues with the ASM. I like Bambu’s plastic reels but as mentioned, too much of their limited choices are out of stock. Will the cardboard reels be an issue with my X1 Carbon and ASM2 Pro? Thanks

I am still new to 3d printing and just use PLA. I’ve used SUNLU and use the basic Bambu filament settings. I haven’t had issues yet. If there specific settings for SUNLU pla+ or silk please let me know…