CAD Files ONLY

Hi,

I see a lot of ‘stuff’ on Makerworld (and other sites)…

I NEVER see a way to filer on the items that actually have CAD files.

I always - want to leverage somebody’s design, and make some modifications to it. But I don’t have Fusion 360 pro to convert stl files to solid object. I DON’T have hours trying to run macros and do feats of presdigitation to get a mesh to a solid body.

I want the actual SOLID BODY design I see in Makerworld (and other sites) - so I can tweak it to my exacting specifications.

HOW???

How can I “filter” Makerworld and others to only show those designs with actual CAD files?

Designing in Dallas

why not just starting from scratch?

I’m not that good. I am not a mechanical engineer or part designer as a professional.

I am a violin player.

But really…why reinvent the wheel. If you need a “wheel-plus” take the actual wheel somebody has already perfected, and just add the plus part that you need.

You would be more lucky to look at platforms like GrabCAD.

but why you want to draw a smiley on your stradivari?

Do you give away your music for free?

I want a peaceful world but I’m not getting that either.

Just because you want something doesn’t mean others should have to give it to you. The people who create the stuff you want source to have goals and desires too - like not handing their designs to people who would steal them.

Not saying that’s what you would do but there are others on MW who absolutely would and do steal. All the time. People don’t want to make it even easier for them.

Yes I do give it away… for absolutely free!

Well if that is true you are the exception to the rule.

Musicians want to secure their investments of time and effort and so do engineers.

Hi Everyone,

Well…look…what if Makerword, Thingiverse and the others websites - had a filter you could apply to only show projects that had CAD files (or only show projects with step files, etc.)

Would that be of value???

Thanks

AJ

Agree a “has source files” filter would be great. Meanwhile a few workarounds: Printables creators often attach STEP or F3D files, so it’s worth checking the files list there, and plenty of designers will share the STEP if you ask in the comments. FreeCAD (free) can turn a mesh into a solid via Part > Create shape from mesh, which works OK on simple, flat-faced parts.

Honestly though, for most tweaks you don’t need a solid body at all. Adding a hole, cutting a slot, adding text or a mount can be done as simple add/subtract operations directly on the mesh. That’s the workflow I built my free browser tool around: import the STL or 3MF from MakerWorld or Printables, add or cut shapes with exact dimensions, then export a 3MF back into Bambu Studio. Full disclosure, I made it: twyk me . It won’t give you the original designer’s feature history, but it skips the conversion headache for typical edits.

I am curious, what kind of models are you downloading that require CAD files for tweaking?

It’s odd, and I’m odd, so I find well-parameterized CAD a joy to work with, even if I don’t change anything. You can get by with shapes and stuff on the slicer a lot of the time. Adding simple flourishes like a fillet in most tools also really prefers to be a solid right now

I´m with you, I don´t download and remix other´s design all that much, because most just include STLs, and I hate converting them to solids, but I always include a STEP file, sometimes the fusion file as well. I wish more people uploaded STEP instead of STLs, but I don´t see that happening anytime soon. All we can do is do it ourselves and hope other people notice and start doing it themselves. But the filter for CAD files is actually a really good one. But then again, the search function isn´t really designed to find exactly what you´re looking for. I would expect when I search “Dummy 13” to have the official design be the first, it never is, so I´ve mostly given up on searching altogether .

Except the engineers that voluntarily contribute to open source.

You should remember that here in 3d printer land, much of the technology used has its roots in the open source community. Also the vast majority of models on makerworld and other such sites are free, and many allow modification and redistribution AKA “remix”

I give away my models for free including print profiles and stl’s, just not the source files.

A filter would be great. Until there is one, here’s a quick way to tell whether a downloaded STL is worth converting at all:

• Mostly flat faces (brackets, boxes, mounts): these convert well. Each flat area becomes one face you can sketch on, cut and extend, so you can treat it like a normal part.
• Holes, rounds and curves: these come back as strips of thin flat faces. You can cut through them, but don’t try to edit them. To change a hole, cut it out with a slightly bigger cylinder and draw the new hole in its place. Same for a rounded edge: fill it back to a sharp corner with a block, then round it again at the size you want.
• Organic or sculpted shapes: don’t convert them. Make the change on the mesh (the slicer can add or cut simple shapes), or remodel the part using the STL as a reference.

So you rarely need the whole design back. You redraw only the one feature you’re changing and leave the rest as it came.

I totally understand this frustration. I’m actually working on something to make STL editing easier.

My idea is to use algorithms to reconstruct CAD geometry and recognize common features, so people can edit downloaded models without spending hours dealing with mesh conversion. For features that algorithms can’t reliably recognize, AI could help as a fallback.

Of course, not every model can be perfectly reconstructed, but hopefully this approach can make editing much easier for most everyday models.

Still a work in progress, but it’s a problem I’d really like to solve!

I offer all of my models as .stp files for that reason. I want people to be able to easily modify them for their best use-case.

I can convet and modify ,stl files, because I’ve got some pretty good CAD skills, but not everyone is like that.