Cannot change to a filament color different than model anymore

I’m having this issue since yesterday where I can’t pick a filament with a different color than the color of the model I’m trying to print. This was working fine before, now it either automatically re-assigns to a filament of the same color on my AMS, or gives me an “unmatch” error. I’ve printed a ton of models with differing colors before yesterday using Handy.

Anyone else have this issue?