You should start the replacement process and swap in one of the spares you received. If it looks poorly seated, reseat it rather than replacing and try again.
Update: The AMS Lite unit was also squeaking while printing PETG. This went away when I took it apart (not recommended) and re-lubed everything. This seems to also fixed the cutting squeak for me as well.
I had the same issue, Only got about 50 hours on the printer, did my first multi color today and it started to annoy me.
After allot ot thinkering and trying stuff i ended up throwing a cutting blade from my P1S on it (because why not…). That did the trick. Looks like the color of the P1 cutting blade isnt the only difference to the ones of the A1.