Full BL Filament comparison chart

I downloaded all the specs sheets from Bambus filaments and fed them into my local Ai (Qwen3.8 27B running in LM Bionic) to make this comparison based on the most important strength parameters, I thought I post it in case somebody else maybe find it useful.

Did any of you buy and try this PLA Sparkle? Either the released data from Bambu labs is incorrect or it is suprisingly strong?? - Until this is cleared up by somebody treat the high score of PLA Sparkle with a grain of sparkle, ah salt…

This was the method they are sorted:

Step 1 — Pick 4 metrics (from each filament’s TDS):

Metric Unit Why it matters
Tensile Strength Z MPa Force needed to pull layers apart (layer adhesion)
Tensile Strength XY MPa Force needed to break the part in-plane
Impact Strength XY kJ/m² Energy absorbed before breaking (shock)
Bending Strength XY MPa Resistance to flexing/bending

Step 2 — Normalize each metric to 0–100% by dividing by the best value across all 33 filaments

Max values used: TS-Z, TS-XY, Impact, Bend

Step 3 — Average the 4 normalized values (equal weight, 25% each)

Here another ranking which might be more accurate, it takes into account that particles like glitter have a negative impact:

I was thinking about putting them in a spreadsheet. So thank you, saves some time.

EDIT: It’s like PLA Aero and TPU 85A are missing, and maybe I still make the spreadsheet to compare the different metrics against each other.

Here is the actual spreadsheet without ranking. Gofile — Cloud Storage Made Simple

Monthly download limit exceeded (1000.18GB/1000GB per 30 days). So I’ll try later I guess.

Strange, try this: Dropbox

I don’t see the use in mixing those different strength values into a single metric.

E.g. sometimes I explicitly look for an impact resistant material because it is used in a workshop were heavier parts might be dropped on concrete floor. Tensile strength isn’t an issue at all because they don’t have to bear any loads worth mentioning. The best materials for that application will probably be hidden by more brittle materials that have higher tensile strength.

And often the best in plane strength doesn’t help when layer adhesion is only a fraction. The better metric in that case would probably be the minimum value of Z and XY tensile strength.

Yep. This makes it really useless for identifying ‘strength’ as the different kinds of strength are individually important. This would imply that PPA-CF is the “best” filament for mechanical things but I can think of a ton of reasons why I would not use that in favor of some other material.

At least BL should have a comparison of the relevant metrics of all their filaments in a chart so they are easy to compare in my opinion, they don´t so I made this.

I have a similar spreadsheet but i put bending and impact strength differently since you generally know which of the 2 you need, based on the function of the part.