How explain product compatibility when not allowed to mention the brand or model

Hi everyone,

I have a question about how to describe compatibility with a branded product when MakerWorld does not allow you to mention that brand name or its model designations.

Let me explain what happened.

About a year and a half ago, I uploaded a 3D-printable magazine loading tool for airsoft enthusiasts. It’s a simple accessory that makes loading BBs into certain airsoft magazines much easier and helps prevent the BBs from being inserted incorrectly.

The tool was designed for airsoft magazines that follow the Glock-compatible magazine standard, including those used by airsoft replicas from manufacturers such as Tokyo Marui, VFC, and Action Army (AAP-01).

The model was quite successful. Over approximately 18 months, it received thousands of downloads, hundreds of likes and boosts, and became one of my more popular designs on MakerWorld.

I never used the Glock logo or any other Glock branding on the actual printed model. I also never claimed that the product was manufactured, endorsed, or officially supported by Glock.

The brand name was only used to explain compatibility. For example, the images included the text “Compatible with Glock Airsoft Magazines,” and the description listed the airsoft manufacturers and replicas that could use the loading tool.

Then, after approximately 18 months, the model was removed from MakerWorld.

I never received an email or notification informing me about the removal. I only discovered it when I wanted to share the model with a friend and could no longer find it.

When I contacted MakerWorld, I was initially told that the appeal period was limited to 20 days. Unfortunately, since I hadn’t been aware of the removal, I hadn’t had the opportunity to respond within that period.

After asking for clarification, I was informed that the removal was related to the use of the Glock brand name in the model’s title and description.

I explained that the brand name had only been used to identify compatibility, not to suggest any official connection with the manufacturer.

I also mentioned that searching for “Glock” on MakerWorld returned more than 1,000 results, which made the situation confusing to me. I genuinely didn’t understand why my model had been removed while so many other models using the same brand name were still available.

MakerWorld subsequently explained that the removal had been made following a takedown request from Glock.

To be clear, I’m not asking MakerWorld to ignore such requests, and I understand that the platform has to deal with trademark complaints.

However, I do find it frustrating that my model could disappear without any notification reaching me, leaving me unable to appeal within the stated deadline.

A MakerWorld representative was eventually kind enough to explain that I am allowed to upload the model again, provided that I do not use the word “Glock” anywhere in the listing.

I appreciate that clarification, but this leaves me with a rather frustrating situation.

I’m allowed to upload my model again, but I’m not allowed to use the very information that tells people what the model is compatible with.

And that’s where I’m struggling to understand the logic.

Why not simply list the compatible airsoft manufacturers and models?

You might think I could simply list the airsoft manufacturers and their compatible models instead.

Unfortunately, that doesn’t really solve the problem.

For example, Tokyo Marui uses names such as Glock 17, Glock 19, and Glock 22 for its airsoft replicas. VFC uses names such as Glock G17 and Glock G19.

And according to the restrictions MakerWorld has explained to me, I’m not allowed to use either the Glock name or model designations such as G17, G19, and similar identifiers.

I could mention Tokyo Marui or VFC, but without identifying the specific models, that information is practically useless. Both manufacturers produce many different airsoft replicas, and my accessory is certainly not compatible with all of them.

Action Army’s AAP-01 is an exception because it has its own model designation, but that only covers a small part of the compatibility range.

So even describing compatibility through the airsoft manufacturers themselves doesn’t provide a workable solution.

I’m not looking for ways to break the rules

I want to make something clear.

I’m not asking for tricks to bypass MakerWorld’s restrictions by deliberately misspelling brand names, using coded references, or hiding prohibited terms in images.

I’m genuinely trying to find a practical and legitimate way to comply with the rules while still making my design available to the people who could benefit from it.

But that brings me to the fundamental problem.

If someone designs a replacement part, an adapter, a protective case, or an accessory specifically for a particular product, how are they supposed to make that part discoverable without identifying what it fits?

How can potential users know whether an accessory is compatible with their equipment if the manufacturer and model information that establishes compatibility cannot be used?

And perhaps most importantly:

If I am allowed to publish the model, but the people who need it have no realistic way of finding it, what is the practical value of being allowed to publish it at all?

My question to the MakerWorld community

I’m genuinely interested in hearing how other makers handle situations like this.

Have you encountered similar restrictions when publishing accessories designed for specific brands or products?

Have you found a practical way to communicate compatibility clearly without violating MakerWorld’s rules?

And perhaps someone from MakerWorld could explain how creators are expected to handle this situation, especially when the usual manufacturer and model designations are also restricted.

I enjoy designing useful things and sharing them with the community. That’s exactly why I published this model in the first place.

I would really like to be able to share it again, but in a way that makes sense for both MakerWorld and the people who might want to print it.

Thanks for taking the time to read this. I appreciate any constructive suggestions or insights!

This is actually quite an old issue, and it tends to come up with certain brands over and over again. Sometimes it’s LEGO, sometimes it’s car manufacturers. Mattel, specifically regarding the use of the word “UNO.”




I could list hundreds of examples like this right now. That wouldn’t make things any better, though. That’s also why you shouldn’t mention other companies at all, not even as “compatible with”, because the AI filters tend to remove or flag those references quite aggressively.


It’s best not to mention other brands at all - at least the companies that don’t want that. Don’t use their logos, don’t include their brand names, and don’t even write things like “compatible with”, because the filters can be absolutely ruthless when it comes to that.


When it comes to certain companies, it’s simply not worth fighting it. If they don’t want their brand referenced, just leave it alone. It saves a lot of headaches and wasted time. It may not be the answer you were hoping for, but plenty of people have already reached the same conclusion.

Otherwise, there are also companies that have no problem with that… maybe you can focus on those.

Take a look at the topics I linked earlier, because this is another point I specifically wanted to address separately.

This exact argument gets posted on the forum every single time. Literally every time. And the answer is always the same: the system is complex, enforcement is often not synchronized, and a lot depends on what rights holders choose to report and when they report it.

Sometimes action is taken much later, even weeks or months. That can create the impression that the process is unfair or inconsistent, and sometime it is, but in many cases, if you check again a month later, most of the other cases have been caught as well. They have to start somewhere, after all.

You were probably just part of the first wave. Seriously, take a look at the other threads. They’re asking the exact same questions and making the exact same arguments. You’re definitely not the only one this has happened to.

IMO just be really annoying about it.

“Works with Clock magazines.”
“Compatible with Rimber 1191.”

Is it a good solution? No.

Does it make searching for it suck? Yes. Probably. The system might allow for ‘misspellings’ to show up in a user’s search though.

Will the community largely understand? Probably.

This is incorrect.

Makerworld’s takedowns for IP infringement are triggered by complaints from third parties.

I should also add these complaints against models that just mentioning a name or model in the description are likely not supported by law, as fair use should apply to these situations.

It should, but people would have to potentially pursue it through the courts in order to prove it sadly :frowning:

At some point @MakerWorld is going to smarten up and realize they’re taking down thousands of legitimate, non-infringing models, which hurts them and upsets the people who contribute to the community. All it takes is one letter telling these leeches to pound sand and the issue goes away.

It would also earn Makerworld a bit of badly needed goodwill.

I don’t know what the point of the Exclusive Program is when it handcuffs designers to a single platform and then that platform takes down these models and confiscates the points for model for completely illegitimate reasons.

Issue with that is it is likely to remove their internet safe harbour status because they are proactively taking a side, so i don’t see them doing that, its down to us to fight our own battles on that front sadly

At this point, it is probably worth acknowledging that Bambu has to do this. They really do not have a choice, as the legal framework requires it.


Of course, people can criticize the IP holders, too - but they are also operating within the boundaries of the law. If anyone want to look for someone to blame, then the legal framework itself is the most obvious place to start.

That is why this is neither a battle nor something worth fighting over here at the forum. This is simply the wrong place for that debate. The right place is where laws are made and changed.


Problems need to be solved at their source, not by fighting their symptoms here in the forum. While it is certainly important and worthwhile to discuss it here, too - that alone will not change anything.

The way I see it, if MakerWorld removes one of my exclusive models (and yes, that’s already happened), I take that as a very clear message from MakerWorld:

“Thank you for keeping your designs exclusive to our platform. As a token of our appreciation, we’d now like to encourage you to publish them on every competing platform instead, now that we’ve taken your model down.”

Message received. Who am I to argue with such a brilliant exclusivity strategy?

Edit:
On a more serious note, I think the takedown process itself needs improvement.

MakerWorld should temporarily remove the model, notify the creator, and give them a proper opportunity to accept or dispute the claim.

If the creator disputes it, the model should be reinstated unless the rights holder takes legal action. That would allow creators to assess the actual claim and decide for themselves whether they’re willing to accept the legal risk.

Especially in cases involving trademark names used solely to describe compatibility, I suspect a court might give the rights holder a rather unpleasant reality check. After all, trademark law does allow the use of brand names to identify compatibility under certain conditions.

Except every platform wanting to keep its safe harbour status has to do exactly the same thing

Sure but that is an expensive mistake if bambu incorrectly allows it to remain on the platform after the rights holder has requested it be removed, unlike youtube that has essentially an infinite budget, bambu doesn’t have the money to defend having to potentially fight every single rights holder that has an infringing model here, it would very quickly ruin a platform, and its why none of them want to risk it

I all fairness I have to say that no points are confiscated. I still have all points I earned with the model.

Thank you for taking the time to explain your point of view. I appreciate it, and I certainly understand that MakerWorld has legal obligations when dealing with intellectual property complaints.

I’m not disputing that trademark owners have rights, nor am I suggesting that MakerWorld should simply ignore complaints from those rights holders.

However, I think there is an important distinction between complying with legal obligations and deciding how a platform handles compatibility information.

As I understand it, EU trademark law does allow the use of registered trademarks under certain conditions when it is necessary to explain the intended purpose of a product, particularly accessories and spare parts. Of course, whether those conditions apply to my particular models is a separate question, and I’m not claiming to have a definitive legal answer.

But that wasn’t really the question I was asking here.

MakerWorld has explicitly told me that I am welcome to upload my models again, provided I remove all references to the protected brand name and related model designations.

That leaves me with a very practical problem.

How do I accurately explain which products my accessories are compatible with, and how can people searching for those accessories find them, if I cannot identify the products they were designed for?

Simply mentioning the airsoft manufacturers doesn’t solve this, because those manufacturers produce many different models, and my accessories only fit certain ones.

I’m not looking for a confrontation with MakerWorld, and I certainly don’t expect a forum discussion to change trademark legislation.

What I’m hoping for is a practical solution that allows me to follow MakerWorld’s rules while still making my designs useful and discoverable to the people who need them.

And I do think this forum is an appropriate place to ask that question, because other makers may have encountered exactly the same problem.

So I appreciate your explanation of the legal perspective, but unfortunately, it doesn’t really answer the question I originally asked.

And that question remains: How are we supposed to communicate product compatibility when the information needed to identify that compatibility is not allowed?

Thanks again for contributing to the discussion.

Just do what other creators do. If they can describe their models without using brand names, so can you. There are plenty of generic terms and descriptions you can use without referring to a specific company or trademark. I’ll give a few examples:

  • LEGO = building blocks
  • Mattel / UNO = card case

If you can’t describe your 3D model using generic terms, then your 3D model isn’t suitable for MakerWorld. Not from my personal point of view, but that’s just how the system works.


Former LEGO fans had to learn that too, and nowadays they just refer to them as “interlocking building bricks” or “construction bricks.”

I’m not really familiar with guns, but a popular search term seems to be without breaking the rules: G17 / G18


By the way, I suspect that’s why they targeted your content first:

The way you present yourself gives off a very commercial impression. Including your website and your large social media presence. That’s probably one of the reasons why your content attracted attention earlier than others. On the other hand, you have a fairly large follower base that you can inform about this. You can explain the situation to them.

Thanks, RetroSharky! I understand your point, and I actually agree with part of it.

Unfortunately, MakerWorld has explicitly told me that G17, G18, and similar model designations are not allowed either, so that doesn’t solve the problem.

As for appearing commercial because I have a website and a large social media following, I can understand that impression. But if I were actually running this as a business, I’d hopefully be making some money instead of spending €100–150 every month on filament and accessories, with the occasional free printer from MakerWorld points as my reward, roughly once a year! :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

For me, this is a hobby that I enjoy sharing with others, not a business.

Well that’s an interesting one I don’t think we have heard before. I wonder what was different about your case. :thinking: