Incorrect print dimensions

Hello,

I’m trying to print small parts with a hollow cylindrical part that should be 8.4 mm but sticks out between 7.9 and 8 mm.
I checked, and the model is indeed 8.4 mm.

The outer diameter provided at 20.4 mm is 19.9 mm.

My filament is white PETG from Bambu, which I calibrated with a flow rate of 0.9677 and k = 0.044.

What’s the problem?

Thank you for your help

Print source: https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:6637299

PiègeBeeVital_RéductionEntrée-0840_MES_PARAMETRES.3mf (273,4 Ko)

You need to calculate the filaments shrinkage, use this tool to do that: ShrinkingTest V4.1 by Alex_vG by Alex_vGMakerWorld: Download Free 3D Models

Thank you I will do that and come back.

hmm, 19.9 instead of 20.4 is quite a lot. that is like 2,4%. I doubt that shrinking alone can cause that. For PETG, I typically have shrinkage values around 0,30% … 0,45%.

I’m a bit puzzled how such a small part can be off that much. No clue.
Still it is certainly a good idea to do the shrinking test and see which values you get.

Alex, look — with you, I’ve worked miracles! Do you remember I used to have holes smaller than 0.3 mm?
After the calibrations, I’m now printing with zero error — I’m measuring with a hundredth-millimeter caliper!
I’m beyond happy. I’m truly grateful to you.

That is excellent news! Congratulations :slightly_smiling_face:
Would you mind sharing the shrinking factor that you calculated? I’m really curious about your result.

@Alex_vG I did your measurement test and got a result of 99.699%.

By entering this result into the slicer, the part width is now 20.28 mm (instead of the planned 20.40 mm).
The hole width is 8.23 ​​mm (instead of the planned 8.4 mm).
So some hundredth-millimeter are missing again…

mes_resulmtats_PETG_blanc

After further trial and error, I obtained a coefficient of 99.112%, which gave me the correct outer diameter for printing.

For the hole, I then had to add another 0.075 compensation in the slicer.