As title says. Is engineering plate worth it for X2D printer?
I was under impression that it has something special to offer when it comes to engineering filaments ABS/ASA etc. but i compared it with regular textured PEI and they both require glue for prints.
I expected that if it’s engineering plate maybe it does not need such gimmicks.
So yeah, is engineering plate worth it? Does it offer some benefits to print quality other than different texture of first layer?
It has nothing to do with print quality other than successful bed adhesion and longevity at high plate temperatures. If you are not having issues with your prints on the plate you have, this one isn’t for you.
While it certainly can be used with any material, I would not primarily purchase it for PLA, PETG, ABS, or ASA because those print just fine on PEI.
It’s really designed for high temp materials running build plate temperatures which may be detrimental to other plates in the long run. PPS, PPA, maybe nylon, possibly polypropylene and polycarbonate (i haven’t tested it with PP/PC yet though), etc.
The catch is needing to use the correct glues for each of those materials.
Edit: Granted, ABS/ASA certainly do require higher temps, so one could purchase it for that, but I find they both print and release from the bed so well without glue that I don’t bother to use the engineering plate for those and I would probably buy a replacement textured plate rather than mess with glue on the engineering one.
I think it is a great option for higher temp materials. I almost all of my ABS/ASA/Nylon prints are done on the engineering plate. I have not had any serious problems with adhesion.
You dont need it though. ABS and ASA will print just fine on the stock textured PEI.
But its also a question about what texture you want on the bottom of your prints.
Always Vision Miner NPA. I’ve ripped off the coating of a few plates without it. I usually see way to much adhesion, rather than not enough. The texture on the engineering plate is pretty agressive.
Though that glue is more of an adhesion promoter, it still allows a thin sacrificial layer.
I have two Bambu engineering plates for my X1C, but I haven’t used them since I bought a BIQU Glacier. The engineering plates require glue for all filaments. I’ve only used glue with the Glacier to prevent warping on some (not all) nylon models. All other filaments have adhered well without glue and released easily after cooling.
I bought the Engineering plate for my H2C because at the time it was the only smooth option for anything besides PLA/PETG (for which I had/have the SuperTack plate). It really works fine and is pretty smooth, but requires glue for everything (I use glue stick). The Glacier has become my default go-to smooth plate for most materials. I do also have a DarkMoon CF plate which is typically (especially) good with nylons, but don’t use it often. And their Satin plate… because I’ll try “anything” before resorting to glue…
OTOH, I did pull out the Engineering plate for something high temperature fairly recently… forget what now (a flat thin piece in PAHT-CF maybe), but anyway after it warped the first time on another plate I didn’t feel like screwing around anymore and dropped some glue stick on the Eng. plate, et voilà. So is it “worth” having in the quiver? Personal choice. For me it has worked as advertised.