I’ve noticed several weeks ago that there is a guy (probably one as the scheme is similar) that is creating automatically a flood of profiles supposedly “corrected, enchanced, optimized”. His published models are always some easy stamps etc. but the main “meat” is his published profiles on the models of other users. Sometimes he upload few profiles in the same minute. He is faking his real prints using AI (always white background, no layer lines, if there is text or pattern then it is shown skewed or with other artifacts. It’s automated. Also the profile itself is just low lvl improvements such as if the original model is 0.16mm for the quality purposes he change layer lines to 0.2, change any other setting to print faster and call it optimization. If you will report several of this profiles then the moderators will “process” such profile but they don’t watch the big picture and don’t ban entire account just the single reported profile (in the meantime the user will upload more profiles than was reported). Just like we must do all the work for moderators like they are not even thinking what they are doing. If they won’t do anything with this now there will be more copycats of such behaviour and with the increasing quality of AI photos soon you won’t recognize real print photo from the fake one.
Here are the profiles (im sure there are more just look for titles for example “optimize parameters, improve printing efficiency”):
Just look around if you could spot more profiles of such type. What do you think? In my opinion that is the middle finger to all real print profiles uploaders that are really printing the models to check the printability.
I am a victim of this/these users as well. I had mentioned in another thread about a profile that used an AI image being uploaded to one of my models. I had the profile removed only to see the exact same profile, same name, same image appear back on my model a few days later, but this time from a different user. One of those users was ‘coffee & tea’ who you have listed there.
I can add bibilaby | Home - MakerWorld to that list as well as this user yeeeep | Home - MakerWorld who is the user that currently owns the bogus profile on my model. That’s right, the exact same profile is back on my model for a third time after being removed twice.
Right, i had the same problem. Reported some ■■■■■■■■ profile that degraded my model and called that improvements. After his profile was removed after some time another appeared with the same name but other user like in your case. I thought i had delusions
That would at least be better than what we have now but those with popular models that get the lion’s share by far of the point skimmers would still have to deal with things they should not have to.
We should have a blanket option to disallow 3rd party profiles. If Bambu wants to give us the option to remove them ourselves it at least circumvents their ponderously slow responses to profile complaints. But I want to just turn them off and be done with it. No having to sift back through all my models to see where someone is siphoning off points.
And people should realize that those posting 3rd party profiles may be violating the license in which case giving Bambu a takedown notice might have more weight. No reposting/redistributing includes on the original model page.
I don’t understand why this is so hard for Bambu to do and still hasn’t been done. The profile point skimmers are making bank big time and the lack of involvement or caring by Bambu makes me wonder why.
Even with the higher popularity models, I am imagining something that would only be 2 options, Approve and Deny, with an option to review it. Or just ignore the notification and never have it posted.
Nope. While it lets the print creator not have to deal with it, they would still be bothered by system notices and burdened by whatever feelings of guilt there might be in having to ignore or deny all the time.
Plus the ignore option hurts the people who are actually trying to help because that is a real fraction of profile posts. They go through the effort to help and then… nothing?
Nope. Again nope.
A setting to not allow 3rd party profiles at all would give those trying to help immediate feedback that the particular user doesn’t want it and they can move on.
Nope. It needs to be something that erects a wall and that wall stays there. No bother. No notices. No needing or feeling the need to reply or pressure to accept.
This isn’t hard. It’s common sense. I already hardly post any of my stuff here now because of all the hassles that are now involved in posting models here. I doubt I’m alone.
If it’s a hard change they could force all points to the designer. This would stop farming and I doubt a designer would report a good profile meaning profile reports could be auto deleted.
That is the other solution. Take away the option of keeping the points. It would immediate de-incentivize point theft while letting those trying to actually help still help.
I was thinking an option when editing a model. Something I could toggle on/off because I know that profile will be re-uploaded a day or two after it gets taken down. I’d like to keep profiles turned off on my Fudgement Day model for a week or two, see if the bot gives up and moves on.
Which this bothering is considerable less than the effort it takes to go through an report profiles. As for guilt, I just wouldn’t take it so emotionally with no personal connection. That person already has their “improved profile”.
While your method takes away the hassle all together, it completely gets rid of having the existing system.
Though the system is abused more than anything, I still think it is important to have.
Just my opinion. The point system makes all of this toxic AF. If someone wants to add a thoughtfully improved profile, power to them. If a scammer is looking to game the point system, F em.
I would also add that it would be good to have an option to block specific users from adding profiles, since we do see people reupload the same profiles after it is taken down.
The whole system is fundamentally flawed. As a designer, you’re responsible for both the design itself and the manufacturing process in this case. The designer is usually the person who best understands how the model is supposed to be printed and which settings are appropriate.
There is no good reason why an unrelated third party should be allowed to interfere with that process. And if the designer chooses poor print settings? Well, that’s their responsibility, along with the consequences. That’s how accountability works.
We have to weigh the pros and cons, and so far third-party intervention has mostly created problems rather than solved them.
People are still free to adjust print settings for their own personal use. That’s not the issue.
The issue is that someone else is given the authority, with Bambu’s approval, to step into the designer’s workflow and override decisions that are part of the design process itself.
People can do whatever they want with their own print settings. However, if we’re being honest, it’s quite questionable to even allow others to interfere in a process they had no part in creating.
@MakerWorld you really need to get your house in order. It would be trivial to flag the behavior of these spammers and freeze their account pending human verification.
Why is this a constant issue that isn’t being addressed?
I don’t think the user profiles should be attached to the model page at all. I would attach them to published successful print ratings if I felt the need to let anyone share them at all.
But then that hurts people like me who will take a model designed for say PETG and make a profile for ABS instead. Maybe a way to have the OP verify and approve them instead.
At risk of sounding insulting, which I don’t intend to give any but worry that I might, I am still going to give my opinion: If a user is sufficiently skilled enough to print ABS at all, why would they also not have the skill to adapt a profile for a change in filament themselves? I feel if the default profiles for filament are not sufficient, then the tweaks are going to be for the printer and user’s specific circumstances.
I can’t help but think that when it comes to profiles that if agreed with someone’s recommendations, why wouldn’t I publish them myself? Having a substandard profile seems harmful to my success if I have a choice in improving it. I suppose though, I can imagine a world in which a change would be beneficial but the original creator no longer is supporting the model that it makes sense to allow a profile to be added to let the model be improved third party.
You know, it is kind of funny. One of the early discussions about 3D printing that I can recall hearing about was about the concept of rapid prototyping. One can print, test and make changes before sending something off to be produced. Software has always had that benefit. Yet despite MakerWorld being part of both worlds, we seem to be heading down a path where the system is in place and no changes are going to be made one way or another. As a lazy and broke person (please, don’t point out how the two can be related, I darn well know) I can understand the one and done attitude but it still is disappointing that nothing seems to be improving despite the constant requests and suggestions for how to do it.
I thought one of the profiles sells the license and the others paid to redistribute. I wonder that in such cases Makerworld is not doing anything. The more like to punish the wide range of Makers.