Well actually, in OnShape, you still own the design. In other words, you get to sell your design to whomever you want. It’s just that you’re also making it public and giving away right to prohibit someone else from making the same product. But this is easily remedied by just not naming your parts with and obvious name. In other words, will all of the millions of other files in Onshape, you would be hiding it in the open. Someone would have to know the name of your file.
Now contrast that with Fusion360. If they find out that you make more than $1,000 with any of you’re designs. Your Free Account will be locked until you pay for the professional version which is in the thousands. Nice guys aren’t they.
With SolidWorks for makers, it’s an in between business model. They let you make as much money as you want but the models are in a locked format that prohibits file sharing. Once opened in that version, you can’t even switch back to the paid version. So if let’s say I took a model from work in the Enterprise license and opened it in my free license on my home system, that file can never be opened again other than by my account on my personal SolidWorks license. All these software companies are D*icks! It’s just a matter of degree. I do think that Autodesk though is going to a special hell for some of their predatory tactics.
On the subject of FreeCad. I really want to like that program but put simply, it’s a klugey science project that has never been fully finished. I mean first off, they just finally released 1.0 after 15 years of beta. I get it, it’s open source but C’mon. Then combine the fact that you can get your design into a corner that you can’t get out of. Their user community is full of a bunch of arrogant academic types who won’t answer your question but they will ridicule you for asking it in the first place, a really toxic forum. And people complain about this one.
I keep FreeCAD on my system solely because it does a few things with STEP and STL conversions that the other programs don’t do as well in their free versions. Fusion360 as an example has prismatic conversions which looks slick but is only available in the $800 personal version whereas FreeCAD’s translation tool is close enough.
While on the subject of the $800 Fusion360 license. I almost took the plunge at the end of 2023 and tried to buy it. They went from $280 to $680 in one year. Talk about predatory, Then they had to backpedal and reduce the price. Why would I trust them after that? I also found it’s load times to be a joke and the fact that you have to update your package every month otherwise they won’t let you open the software. To me it’s just a toxic user experience overall. SoldidWorks is much worse experience, the product is a bloated pig, but at least they only charge $90/yr.
This is one of the reasons I’ve become such a huge fan of OnShape. I fire up my browser and in seconds the model I was working on is on my screen where I left it. Even if I lose power or Internet, I never loose my work. Also, they have time-based rollback feature which the others don’t have. So if I want to go back two hours in the timeline I can. I don’t have to use the history tree. It also has unlimited redo(CTRL-Z) history. Or at least I have never reached their limit.
That said, I still have trepidations because OnShape is owned by PTC who has a rich reputation of being predatory but at least for the last 7 years, they have left OnShape alone.