Before I get on a rant I want to say that I agree 100% on the slop. I wouldn’t want to show anything in bad form. However, this decision to have slop should be the creators own choice, and would be on them, if the outcome is good or bad. Personally I don’t mind bad prints when they make my prints look good. Let me see if I understand this right? The person’s prints and brownie points are removed because of slop, injection molding, and showing no effort? So why wasn’t the person asked to change or remove the photo or print? Did this person get any type of warning stating that their photos and print was unacceptable before they were removed, giving time to rectify this displeasing situation? Or did they just remove it? Again, this is from what I understand.
The Dot Idea: Why didn’t I turn the dot print in? I chuckled and showed it to some friends. All I could think of is the pet rock and how the creator made millions. People were actually downloading that dot! That’s what I found hilarious but the dot Idea was absolutely stupid and genius at the same time. It never crossed my mind to think it was unacceptable because it was allowed to be uploaded by the company. I had no Idea that there was a cleansing going on in the 3D printing world regarding slop and bad photo representation. It would seem to me that making a rule of only real photos and good clean prints should be allowed when showcasing. That would eliminate all of this AI photo complaints and bad photo judgments from continuing. The AI photos are going to be a hard one because this company invested in and promotes AI in different ways.
Ok, let’s go with the idea that there is nothing suspicious with waiting years before spanking the individual by removing their print and brownie points over an unacceptable photo and slop. I am all for cleaning up, but it would be more acceptable to me if it was a recent violation and not from years past. After a while the “nit picking” monster could emerge. It could turn on those who are trying to clean the mess up if allowed too much rope from not being careful with the rules that are changed on the fly.
If caught red handed with a violation then I agree to remove the print. However, I suggest that a way to show verification to a real person, or request to make an effort to fix the problem, or even receiving a warning email, giving an amount of time for the accused to respond. I believe this is not done and the reason is that they just don’t care when making a choice regarding who they go after. Why? It’s because they are relying on AI. If they took this seriously, they would care about both sides of the coin and not just their opinion. You would also get a real person on the other end of the phone line. I believe that they are not willing to take the time and look at every case through the eyes of a human. I’m not sticking up for this person but I am for those who are truly wronged. So with this I ask, was this man aware of the mission to remove unacceptable prints and photos a head of time and why remove them now from years past? If this AI judges prints and cover photos, it will be hard to get an acceptable ruled compliance in the future with files. If enough individuals ask for someone to change the rules, they will eventually get it or something close to it. I will personally keep tabs on this progression of selective acceptance hoping it doesn’t bite me in the future because of the demands of others. I think I will keep my printing off line until the purge is over and evaluate the aftermath before making any decisions. I personally believe obj, gltf, stl, and 3mf are mathematical molds. The nozzle is the injection point so in theory the 3D printer is an injection molding machine. I have actually worked with one of those very machines. Peace be with you all!