It is unfortunate that the de facto “leaders” of the forums contribute so much amazing information and exploratory posts but then turn around and demean people who don’t find their info interesting or aren’t as invested in a new topic as they are. They are a tricky sort who never actually type out put downs or insults, to avoid being called on it later. If you read enough of their posts and comments (which isn’t difficult as there are so many) you will start to get the true sense of what some of their messages are. They hide behind tricky and vague language that is up to interpretation to put down less knowledgeable people or skeptics, and then typically follow it up with “high horse” phrasing or words (or emojis) that come across as “smug”.
If you read back enough of their responses to people who are trying to disagree or just inquire further about a topic when they don’t have the same knowledge base, you can see what I mean. The problem isn’t any one post or reply, but rather the picture of these users that is painted by reading their communications over time. Try reading their responses in a neutral tone, a helpful tone, and then a demeaning tone. In my personal experience, and seemingly several others, the demeaning tone always fits their words better.
They will assuredly come around and attempt to say they did nothing wrong, or they were just trying to be helpful, or ask you to provide a specific sentence that is insulting. They know that they can’t be proven wrong as they are careful to write things that are open to interpretation so that they can always highlight the best interpretation should they be referenced and could categorically deny that there is any other way to read their words. Of course, this does not mean every post by them is like this, which muddies the waters.
Typical responses to criticism are:
- Use the block button! (ignoring community effects of their behavior in favor of saying to just turn a personal blind eye)
- It’s your own personal opinion, no one else is saying this… (people have definitely stated criticism and what’s more there are people who leave the forum without saying anything due to their behavior, I know this personally)
- Using a specific word in your post that has a meaning they will harp on (you brought up a good point but then you colored it with an emotional verb? They pounce on the verb choice and ignore the content)
- Disdain that you formatted your response oddly because you don’t have English as your first language (they keep telling you they can’t read your response well and with enough time they just tell you they will ignore your comments from then on)
- Attacking the user themselves instead of their words (choosing to demean character over content, such as looking at someone’s profile to evaluate their CAD skill, writing skill, or the nature of their models and talk about those instead)
- Refusing to read long posts (you spent a lot of time writing something you are passionate about and it disagrees with them? They will use TL;DR as a justification to stop paying attention)
They are in better control of their emotions which allows them to write sentences designed to infuriate those who disagree with them. They will never allow themselves to make bald statements like “You suck!” as then they would have nothing to hide behind. If they can provoke an emotional reaction out of someone else, they can point the finger and say, “You aren’t behaving!”. In this way, they can eventually push people out of the forum under the guise of ridding the community of an angry person who doesn’t contribute as much as they do. It is very difficult to call out these kinds of people, and if they are doing it unknowingly then it is very difficult to actually show them reality of what is happening without them falling back to their ironclad self-justifications. The intentional ones are always the people who say “allegedly!” or “why don’t you prove it (smug emoji)”.
I don’t really see how their behavior is defensible to them, and they may root around to find a way or just simply ignore this. Hopefully they can do better and improve the general vibe of the forums.
On its face, BL forums seem to be a bit of a haven from typical online behavior but there are cracks forming as a result of these issues. If you are going to be this prominent in the community, it should come with a greater sense of responsibility and care towards all manner of members of said community. You may not have set out to be that type of user, but your widespread and dedicated involvement has made you that kind.
I do not claim to be that kind of user in any way, and in fact this an account not linked with anything that I personally do as I have had many online experiences in the past 20 years with people creating strawmen or using whataboutism instead of directly facing the words I use. I have been on almost every kind of forum and content aggregator there is in that time. My standing as a simple member of the community should be enough to mean that these power users should take note. I have a lot of read time on this account, on others, and as an anonymous reader before that.
I don’t expect a response to this as I didn’t name anyone specifically, so responding back would be some kind of power play thing, which is not my intention. Hopefully at least someone will read this and take it to heart. When multiple people share a specific issue with someone, they may have a point.
To the de facto prominent community leaders: You need to do better with the way you treat others because you have put yourself on a visible pedestal in the forums with your vast contributions and experiences.