We make drying cabinets for 3D printing, and during our own testing we found something worth sharing. In a room that sits around 60% RH, open spools pick up enough moisture to cause stringing and rough surfaces within a few days. Sealed storage with desiccant fixed it for us. We also noticed the printer itself runs more consistent when the spools feeding it stay dry. Curious how the rest of you handle storage in humid climates.
I dry my filament to an initial RH% value less than 10% at room temperature then store in Praki polyethylene containers with a hygrometer and 50g packet of dry silica gel beads.
That can hold RH% below 10% at room temperature for well over a year if the seal is good.
System works very well and prints show no water effects.
Will be moving to Sunlu’s i10 dehydrator cabinet when those ship out.
AMS with ABS, PETG, and ASA. Ran a dry cycle 13 days ago then popped in some freshly regenerated alumina desiccant in a full set of PPS-CF printed cartridges. I have opened it 3-4 times since then.
RH was reading 2% yesterday after I opened it and loaded in 2x ASA spools, one of which was freshly opened. This morning it reads 0% again.
For longer term storage I am currently evaluating vacuum bags with indicating silica and a partial vacuum. There’s some concerns that the bags are permeable (they are) and that they partition the desiccant packs from the filament (they do), however it’s my belief that the partial vacuum alone is sufficient to lower the amount of total moisture that can make it’s way into the filament by lowering the vapor pressure, and that should be accounted for.
So far after just about 1 month of storage this way in my basement, which I keep at 45% RH, my PETG came out string-free. The indicating silica was still showing as ‘good’.
That said, I don’t have the meters necessary to monitor this, and am also waiting for the sunlu cabinet.
I’d be curious what the humidity value of that PETG was. The plastic bags do work, especially if thick-walled, but they do also leak up.
Not a death sentence but many just leave filament in bags for long periods and it can bite them.
True point about the vapor pressure. It starts low but climbs.
When I end up in a corner and need to use plastic bags, I double and triple bag to also set up gradients that slow water getting in.
No idea, but the AMS didn’t seem to notice any increase beyond opening the lid, which came back down within an hour or so.
I have not used these bags long enough to have an opinion that’s worth anything yet. Over my ~11 years of 3d printing I mostly just threw everything on a shelf then tossed it into a dryer the day before I wanted to print anything. With this H2S all the fiddly problems that always limited how often I would start a print are basically gone and I have this huge backlog of projects that are getting done, so keeping my filament ready to go has gone up in priority severely.
I’ve found once filament is dry, it takes a while to pick up much water and touch-up drys can even be deceiving. When I put filament showing humidity on its hygrometer into the dryer it looks like it’s already dry but it actually isn’t that dry (by the hygrometer) and still needs time in the dryer.
But bags are fine as long as people are aware of the water infiltration issue and their ambient humidity isn’t too high or they don’t leave the filament with that being their only protection for too long. And/or re-dry as needed.
The 0% reading after a month is strong. The vapor pressure point is real, a partial vacuum slows water getting in even if the bag is slightly permeable.
Also agree that a surface hygrometer reading can lie right after a dry cycle, the filament can still be wet in the middle.
Solid setup. Sub-10% RH for over a year with silica is genuinely impressive.
On the i10, that is a single-spool dryer while bulk storage cabinets solve a different problem. Curious how it compares once you get it.
The i10 holds 10 rolls. It is not a single spool system, but technically its not a dryer either. Technically.
But if it can maintain 10% RH it will very slowly dry things.
Totally agree. Factory spools pick up water. A bulk storage cabinet with even moderate dryness can help keep them from getting brittle.
Are you thinking of the Sunlu S2? It’s a single-bay dryer and what I use with a dry air purge.
Right, the S2 is the single-bay unit. We were not thinking of any specific model, just that class of dryer. S2 with a dry air purge is a clean combo, curious how the purge holds up over time.
I’ve been doing it for over two years now and it was like night and day for drying and printing. It’s really simple - a medium-size aquarium pump blowing a stream of air through a bottle of silica gel beads. The dry air out just gets plumbed into the Sunlu S2.
The whole routine is to start drying the spool with a door prop to hold the S2 open about an inch at the edge for the big bolus of water that comes off first. Once the humidity in the box starts dropping I close the lid, start the dry air, and let it run for the rest of the dry.
When spools cool, they will pull a Praki down below 10%. I used some old beads that have picked up some water to dry a spool and the exit air was still below 10% and the spool pulled a humidity value around 8% RH at room temperature. I was clearing out some old Drierite from the same experiments and it was still able to pull down to 2% RH as reported by an SHT45 temperature/humidity sensor. That dried filament fast (implying the beads don’t stay quite so low) but is has low water capacity.
It works great and there just are no water effects. The maintenance issue with the Prakis is really the only down side but any spools bleed up and a dry touch-up fixes it. I don’t have to guess about the dry. It works every time. I dry my filament to 18-19% RH at temperature and put them in a Praki with a hygrometer and add a dry silica gel pack only after the filament itself has pulled the RH at room temperature to below 10%. That’s my check that the filament got a good dry.
I use indicating beads and regenerate when the color change nears the end of the column. My larger air dryer has enough capacity to dry air for drying about 50 or so spools. The beads are removing water from the room air which is much less water than trying to soak up water liberated from a drying spool so they last a long time.
As a fallback, as long as the cabinets are tight, if the Sunlu can’t actually hit and hold 10%, I will just plumb dry air into the cabinet and probably have lower humidity than the Sunlu can hit on its own. Manual regeneration though. The beads in the dry air generators need manual regeneration the way I did it but they last a long time.
The aquarium pump trick is a good one, beads pulling from room air last way longer than when they soak up a hot spool.
Also respect the 18-19% target, then waiting for the spool to pull below 10%. Most people trust the hygrometer and call it dry too early.
I wish I could claim it but can’t. I think it was @IslandBill who came up with that one.