X2D vs P2S level of complexity

Hello people of the internet, I will get a new printer next month, initially I was planning on getting an X2D with the AMS, but I’ve been reading and some users are having a lot of headaches with it.

I mainly want the new printer to print multicolor, and at first the X2D seemed very interesting because of the dual nozzle, however I’ve read that some people are having issues using the Bowden extruder, that it needs a lot of configuration.

The other printer I’m starting to consider is the P2S because it seems its easier to use and less things can go wrong, but im not sure if the “complexity downgrade” is a good idea.

I’ve been on this hobby for a couple of years, starting with an old prusa and then an A1 mini. What i liked about the bambulab is that it required minimal configuration.

What do you guys think? Is the X2D much harder to use and more problematic than a P2S? I don’t plan on using engineering materials, i mainly use pla and some petg (but who knows?). Is avoiding some manual configuration worth in exchange for the dual nozzle?

You always read the worst. The people that are pissed off are always the loudest.

Both of them are good machines. Both of them have a few minor issues.

You would be happy with either. But be ready to do some tuning on the secondary nozzle.

If possible I would hold out awhile longer and at least see if Bambu announce any new printers in the next month. If they do a P2S size Vortek printer, a bit more expensive but probably worth it.

I do have a few P2S that do multicolour and they are quite reliable and not too complex to fix common issues, but they produce alot of waste.

I have the X2D and had my fair share of problems.Here is the thing though, i also had old skool printers that makes this a dream (imagine trying to level turning knobs by the smallest amount and using a piece of paper to guestimate its level to the nozzle). This tech isnt 100% yet from any brand or any model.

part of the 3d printing world is something you must learn and adapt to many situations. your humidity levels in your house, your temp in your house, how you store, what to do and how to investigate when they go wrong (and they will). some of the time, it isnt the fault of the printer. Things like a crappy roll of filament can give your hours of nightmares. i just had that with 3 nozzles being taken out by a crappy filament clogging them. And that happens with decent brands of filament too, not just cheap ones.

All in all, both will be fine, i would say play to your budget more.

Has anything been confirmed or rumored so far? A printer like that sounds interesting, but I was planning on buying during the black friday sale​:sweat_smile:

I remember doing the paper thing, traumatic​:joy:.

In this case the price difference isn’t much of an issue. But I would be willing to spend a bit more if they release a multi head one like the other user said :thinking:

There is talk in other posts here showing Bambulab patents or something for two new printers, a P2S and H2 size with likely multi nozzle

My X2D is my first plastic printer, so I can’t compare to the P2S, but I can say that no in-depth configuration was needed to get it working well. I just went through the standard assembly and setup procedure (which is 100% described in the online manual), and it worked great.

There are a few highly recommended printable add-ons. 1) A cover glass riser. 2) Fan outlet deflectors. 3) Poop basket (which is commonly needed for many printers).

However, there was a substantial learning curve for using Bambu Studio. I’ve been printing regularly for 4 months, and I’m still learning many of the settings in Bambu Studio.

If you are interested in multicolor, have you considered the U1? I think I would prefer my X2D over the U1 because the AMS 2 Pro makes filament swapping and drying so convenient, but just tossing that out there.

Hi, I bought a X2D 1 week ago after a month of thinking which one I should buy, and I had the same concerns about the various forum threads. At the begining of my journey I decided to take a P2S, but then I came to the X2D. And during various internet searches I was not sure which one to buy. Creality, Anycubic, Snapmaker came to my mind, but at the end I ended up with the X2D again, and I’m glad I did it. It’s a fantastic device, even with the 2nd bowden extruder. I’m printing now a lot of stuff since 3 days and I’m really more than happy. This is my first private 3d printer, but I started a lot of years ago with a Zortrax m200 which was a nightmare sometimes feeding the filament into the extruder. The X2D is really a good choice in my opinion.

I am trying to resell the X2D I bought to experiment with. I’m too much of a perfectionist to tolerate the main vs aux setting tuning. Additionally I didnt find it to be flexible enough for modern multimaterial including TPU, as the TPU basically must be on the main for good quality, and must not be AMS’ed during a print or youll frequently jam… leaving you to tune a bank of AMS materials thru an ender 3 extruder. No thanks.

To be fair, I never encountered a single “multi nozzle” hardware calibration issue, at all. Offsets “just worked” and every swap always succeeded. And it is VERY fast to switch, which makes it overall a very fast printer.

[ opinion that i refuse to spend more time on disproving ] I also deeply suspect that Bambu is playing games in their firmware with “bambu pla” vs “generic pla” pressure advance autocalibration, making the generic purposely less auto accurate. It obeys faithfully when you manually do the test and set it; but automatic noticably works better when the software thinks you are using genuine, even if you are NOT, all other subfilament settings held constant. [/opinion]

Of your choices, I’d select the P2S+AMS2. The built in light-duty dryer into the AMS2 is actually pretty awesome and an underrated thing - saves benchtop space. Qidi box does it too.

I’m probably one of the people you’ve seen unrecommending the printer in the comments.

You mentioned you want to print multicolor. You need to keep in mind X2D does not give a significant filament savings printing multiple colors. And in some cases it even takes more time to print with 2 heads, than it would have been with a single head.

The $100 price difference is probably more than the filament you’ll save by using this printer throughout its lifetime.

There are reasons to choose X2D over P2S (mostly better sensors). But multicolor printing is not a very strong one.

And despite what people write in the comments - it is significantly more complex. You might not notice it while it’s working fine and you don’t have any issues (especially if you don’t have both printers to compare). But I guarantee it you’ll notice it if god forbid something goes wrong with the extruder (one of the 2), and you need to replace some internal parts.

FYI for more than 2x colors like 4x and more. the X2D has no benefits as it will switch too much anyway. Ideally you will need second AMS 2 PRO which is around +300$/EUR. And maybe also filament track switch + ~60$/EUR

Something else interesting is PETG is not well on the AUX. Some other filaments too.

0.2mm nozzle is also not really recommended as you can see below. And many filaments are not good for the track switch also.

Strongly recommended to check the filament compatibility chart:

Then if you need to use TPU or engineering stuff you may need to disconnect the PTFE tubes or disconnect the AMS to feed directly.

What else I would recommend if you figure out your set up should be working fine with materials that you have. You may like to get in Bambu Studio, add X2D by hand, the upper right corner and compare some common projects when sliced, how much time they will take. How much filament will be consumed and etc. Then you can do the same with P2S. Even you can open the same file in 2-3 Bambu Studio sessions and compare.

Next to this very few people here are able to make Ironing working good. If this could be a thing for you.

I print PETG from the aux nozzle all the time for actual print structure, not as support or support interface. Zero issues and looks great. Others have shown this too. Unfortunately, you’ve got a problematic X2D. I’d be pushing Bambu hard for a replacement.

FYI I do not have issues with the AUX extruder so far. But Bambu do not recommend it for PETG especially with track switch, and provided profiles are really bad. I had two weeks of absolute nightmares of stringing and oozing with Polymaker PETG on the AUX. Which was absolutely fine on the main. Then I moved to azure film and it was OK. Kind of day and night but again very slow.

I have no quality issues with the AUX though and I can print multi color PLA prints all day long. Just finished two micro pugs in 3 colors - around 3 hrs, at 0.1mm. And look good. Support may need tuning though.

I can not request replacement printer just like this, as first I bought from local, and second I am far away from replacement window. So I need to play a long game of prove the issue, fixes and etc. And I do not have other printer for now. Although the issues more like cosmetic for me, they are real and show poor QA. Then there are issues from bad design which can not be fixed with replacement printer. I plan to get another printer then bring this back to the shop to figure it out. As I do not have much time for DIY warranty fixes. At least I know what and where to look when I get other printer, does not matter from Bambu or someone else.

I’d say yes and get the P2S, but note the X2D has the finer belt pitch.

FYI I think good take on level of complexity is related to the profiles. As I have explained here:

As you really need to set up two different extruders. You can not just copy paste settings between them.

This thread is really interesting.

I am in the process of choosing between the P2S or the X2D.

my question is can the X2D print two colors out of one AMS? or should the second support color be on the external feed?

It can print 2 colours out of the AMS but it needs to switch filaments as the AMS can only feed one filament at a time. If you want true two colour printing, then you have to have a different source feeding each nozzle.

Hi everyone, jumping into this thread because I’m facing the exact same dilemma choosing between the X2D and the P2S, and I’d love to get a few extra perspectives based on what’s been discussed here.

To give a bit of context on my setup:

  • I’ve been using an A1 Mini for about two years with great satisfaction. It’s been a reliable workhorse and a great learning tool for basic maintenance, 3D design, and dialing in settings in Bambu Studio.

  • I’m now looking for a larger build plate and the capability to reliably print ABS and ASA.

  • I print purely for personal hobby projects (mostly tabletop terrain and miniatures) in my home office. I can ventilate the room by opening windows, but I don’t have a dedicated external exhaust system.

  • Having a dual nozzle system for dedicated support materials (soluble or break-away) would be a very welcome feature for fine mini details, though not an absolute dealbreaker.

Given the points raised about complexity and features, from your experience: does stepping up to the X series make sense for a purely hobbyist workflow like mine, or does the P2S hit the sweet spot for home ABS/ASA printing without unnecessary overhead?

I’m not looking for a simple “buy X” answer, but rather any food for thought or practical insights to help me weigh the choice. Thanks in advance!

Now if you keep the mini X2D will do the job for the ASA and ABS. But for big details it is still hit or miss. Even people with H series get troubles when try to print tall things. Cooling/heating could be very aggressive in different ways and scenarios. And not easy to control at present.

And you will need good ventilation or you are playing with your health. Basically for heated chamber and second nozzle for basic stuff, not too many other options. Sad but true.

Also get it from place with good return window and if you do not get similar quality to what you get from the mini return it right away. And do not agree anything half working or start replacing parts from the day/week one!