With topics like this, the big question is always: Are they really ‘free’? As a user, all you have to do is sign up to MakerWorld and click ‘Download’, but what about the bigger picture?
The models were uploaded under the Standard Digital Licence, which does not allow for remixes or any other use. However, I’m almost certain that this isn’t valid because the IP (Nintendo) and concept of the 3D model, namely the ‘clicky Poké Ball’, already existed beforehand.
Furthermore, as the creator, you earn a significant amount of real money from uploading it as an exclusive model. You also gain material value in the form of hardware. In this case, I estimate that we’re talking about several thousand dollars, including the donation account. There’s nothing wrong with that - quite the contrary. I’ll get right to the point:
It’s just not ‘free’ in the traditional sense anymore. If someone supporting the MakerWorld ecosystem and getting paid, everything’s fine - that’s what most of us do. The only tricky part is trying to convince the IP holder that it was, after all, ‘free’. He’ll say, “Wait a minute, you made a thousand dollars off that - that’s the exact opposite of ‘free’ in the true sense of the word.”
That’s why it’s also extremely complicated from a legal standpoint. The line between fan art and commercial art is crossed if you make a lot of money from it.
Like I said, I’m not in a position to judge, nor am I a lawyer, but either way, I see this as playing with fire. This will probably go on until Nintendo finds out, just like what happened with Lego (the name and logo, not the bricks) at MakerWorld - and then it’ll be gone. On the other hand, I assume it’s worth it if we roughly add it all up - a few thousand dollars in hardware value and donations.