If the roughly 200 bucks between P1S- and P2S-combo makes a difference for you, go for the P1S.
The P2S has undoubtedly several improvements over its predecessor, but none of them is a game changer.
The small screen was never a problem for me - I operate the printer over my Mac.
The camera of the P1S is bad, but to let you see how your print is going, it’s good enough.
The P1S has no or less fancy failure recognition (because of its poor camera). But read the forum how often you get false positives using these features.
The P2S has a quick change nozzle, what would appeal to me at most. But there are several reports on these nozzles, that they are baked to the hotend.
The P1S is reliable!!! The P2S still has to prove.
The sum of them is a gamechanger - at least for me. Owning a P1S and a P2S i can tell for sure.
If it’s a question of money I would rather consider skipping the AMS and buying it later. For multi colors you can change the filament manually every layer (not within) - you can’t make a P2S out of your P1S. You could even purchase a used AMS1 to save money.
The P2S ist reliable, so far. The P1S has proven. But reached the end of its development.
After 5000hrs on my P1S and 500hrs on my P2S I can tell you the P1S is much more reliable and consistent. My P2S is reminding me of my Ender 3 days where I spend more time tinkering with it to get consistent results, where as my P1S just worked, and worked, and worked some more.