I had two profiles with photo for 1 year online. they taken down all two because there is an indiot that continue to report me, and makerworld staff, when you continue to report someone before or after take down his model… they reply on ticket to upload a single profile with two versions… and this is what I do.
the difference is only 2 mm hole more deeper… print is the same.
today they taken down because for them I make a profile with two versions and one photo. (but there were two photos… is impossible to see deep in a hole)
profile taken down because it was scaled…
they sais"We would like to kindly inform you that when a model is licensed under the Standard Digital Licence or NoDerivatives, profiles uploaded by other users are only allowed to adjust the print parameters of the file. It is not permitted to make any modifications to the geometry of the model itself, e.g. scaling, clipping, mixing, adding negative parts,etc.
For more details, please refer to our Print Profile Upload Guidelines: MakerWorld Print Profile Upload Guidelines | Bambu Lab Wiki
Thank you for your understanding and commitment to our community standards."
so the profile cannot scale an existing model because it is considered a remix and violates license rules also if in rules there is written that scale a model is not considered a remix? do I have understood? it seems very convoluted
If you take a model from someone else and just scale it up, then you don’t upload it as a remix as it is not considered remixing. You upload it as a Print profile to that existing model.
But uploading a Profile with a scaled model is not allowed when the original model uses the Standard digital license or NoDerivatives license for example which don’t allow any changes made to it (Other than infill, direction etc. I.e hings that don’t change the geometry)
sorry but I really can’t understand… if scale is not considered a remix (and there are millions of profiles with scaled model) why should it be considered as remix when you upload it as a model profile? moreover in this case as the only profile of the model and the designer who had also put it as a favorite profile?
moreover you should know that the same profile had been deleted for lack of photos (this was the reason) after more than a month I won the appeal, and they did not mention problems in scaling. they did not tell me anything. they only restored it, after this given that there is an asshole who has targeted me and systematically reports my models trying every time with different reasons, today they took it down for another reason, precisely for the scale. wouldn’t it be better to be clearer from the start?
Just because someone does it, doesn’t mean you can as well. They might still exist because they, just like you didn’t know or because they just have gone under the radar and no one reported them. Maybe they did more changes other than scaling.
There can be 100 profiles, there can be 1. Rule is rule.
in their message they said that the profile violate license for scale that is a remix and the license does not allow it.
also they point to a page of rules…
in rules there is written that scale is not a remix…
I continue do not understand… maybe for the language, maybe I am stupid…
No, there is no mention of it being a remix. You are reading / translating the message wrong.
Bambu says (and i rephrase it): You uploaded a profile of a model with changed dimensions. The original author does not allow changed dimensions. That’s why we deleted your profile.
As for the guidelines bambu says:
We do not consider the changing of dimensions (scaling) as a remix. [This is referring to uploading the whole model as a Remix, it is NOT referring to print profiles.]
Please upload it as a profile instead, IF the license allows it. If it does not allow it, you can’t upload the models itself, nor post it as a print profile.
We do not consider the changing of dimensions (scaling) as a remix. [This is referring to uploading the whole model as a Remix, it is NOT referring to print profiles.]
if you see well in profile reasons of taken down they link rules… and in rules linked there is not written what are you try to explain. I accept your explanation and this maybe is the real reason… but it is not written or specified in rules…
sorry but what are you saying? the original model of remix is correctly linked… everywhere… what is disingenuous? so now I also cannot ask boost on remix models?
yes I confuse because there are not specifications on profile rules…
They told you. You wrote that information in your post.
It is not my fault that they do not make all the rules more public.
Take it up with them.
I would recommend you add your models from now on, not print profiles. Add value that way.
Unless you add real value, do not bother with profiles.
I used to add colours to some models when the designer only provided a single colour version. That adds value, and the designer is usually fine about it. Always best to ask, though, before you do it.
I ask always before… and as I wrote the profile was the only one and also marked as preferred by the designer… so with desiger there is no problem…
I know it’s not your mistake, of course but they cannot ask us to follow what they don’t write!
I have 52 tickets unsolved… they respond in public just to be safe when something is not clear and clean, they don’t really want to solve the problems, they just want to erase points to save a few miserable dollars…
tell me where this is written, this is in contrast with creative commons and all license… a scale cannot be considered a violation, and PROFILES are intended to offer a ready experience to users… this don’t violate any rules… in makerworld and in other sites…
you are giving as an example a file license.
STFL is a file license. and the file license doesn’t allow remix. scale as specified in makeroworld model rules is not considered a remix but minor change.
they have to decide if the profile going under file rules this is not a remix. if it is not going under file rules… it can be considered a profile rule, but they have to specify on profile rules… that’s it… this is not magician, vocabulary of the language.
they can’t consider the word remix when it suits them and not consider it when it doesn’t suit them, they can’t apply rules without writing them, and above all they can’t invent rules that go against the law. these people are trying to recover small change!! this is the reason!
I’m not sure why you are repeating the “remix” argument since print profile rules have nothing to do with remix rules.
So apparently when you create a print profile you are not allowed to modify or scale the model, just as simple as that.
That said, for me that is an absurd rule. I have multiple models with complex mechanics that may or may not work when scaled. For instance my roll up chess board:
I designed it to be printable on a 200*200mm machine but one user scaled it down to A1 mini size and it still worked so I welcomed him to upload his print profile
Multiple people have also printed it at a larger scale (A1/P1) with success (not with a print profile) and today I got this comment:
Brilliant! Waiting for profile for larger one (full build plate?)
I am not going to create that print profile since I don’t want to print it, but if somebody would I would be happy (more options for users), the uploader would be happy (extra points) and the user would be happy with his larger chess board
So why is this not allowed? For me it would be mutually beneficial. Scaled and tested print profiles are a positive thing in my opinion
