What’s the rule (if there is one) about posting my models on multiple 3D print websites? Does it preclude me from getting any points on MakerWorld if I also post in on Printables or Thingyverse, etc.?
Generally there is no rule against sharing your prints on Makerworld and other websites, unless you mark it as exclusive. The exclusive program requires that your model only exists on Makerworld. So as long as you don’t plan on making it exclusive, you can gain points normally when you post your model on Makerworld.
2 Likes
You can post your 3D models on multiple platforms like MakerWorld, Printables, and Thingiverse without any issues. However, if you choose to participate in MakerWorld’s Exclusive Model Program, your model must be exclusively available on MakerWorld for a specified period. During this exclusivity period, the model cannot be posted on other platforms.
Participating in the Exclusive Model Program offers benefits such as the ability to convert points into cash and receive legal support for copyright infringements.
If you do not opt for the Exclusive Model Program, you are free to share your models across multiple platforms without affecting your ability to earn points on MakerWorld. The points system on MakerWorld rewards various activities, including uploading models, print profiles, and engaging with the community.
In summary, unless you participate in the Exclusive Model Program, posting your models on multiple 3D printing websites does not preclude you from earning points on MakerWorld.
1 Like
Are there any advantages to posting models on other sites?
Seems like it would be just the opposite. Just to make sure I understand-- I can gain points if I DON’T mark it exclusive. I’ve posted before and don’t remember the option to post exclusive (or not). And if I make it exclusive to MW (which I would think they would prefer), then I don’t get points. Hmm.
Besides sharing your creativity, I have not found any advantage - though If you sell your prints online for people to copy and either display/sell themself then sure show a license and a link for them to purchase rights.
Okay-- this is what steers me to MW only. Thanks
1 Like
How would anyone get a license for simply modeling something, especially if it’s not unique?
Edit: One other thing-- In this thread, there is mention of points and cash. Are they interchangeable. Can one opt for cash instead of points? Can one opt for points instead of cash?
The question of licensing for modeling something, particularly if it’s not unique, often comes down to intellectual property (IP) laws and the context of the design in question. Here’s how it typically works:
-
Original Creations: If a model is entirely original and demonstrates a unique expression of creativity, the creator can claim copyright for their work. This gives them exclusive rights to distribute, reproduce, or license the design.
-
Non-Unique or Functional Objects: If the model replicates something that is purely functional or lacks originality (e.g., a generic shape or public domain object), it may not qualify for copyright protection. However, if the design incorporates elements of creativity, like artistic embellishments or novel features, it might still be protected.
-
Licensing: A creator can grant a license for their model regardless of its uniqueness, as long as they have the rights to the design. A license is essentially a contract that allows others to use the model under specific terms. This could apply even to simple designs if the creator has made some effort to develop or publish the model.
-
Third-Party Rights: If the model is based on an existing product, trademarked design, or copyrighted material, obtaining a license from the original rights holder may be necessary. For instance, modeling a famous character or a patented item would require permission.
-
Community Standards: In platforms like Makersworld or others supporting 3D printing communities, the expectation of originality and licensing varies.
To sum it up -
Users often voluntarily respect licenses like Creative Commons, but enforcing them can be challenging unless there’s clear evidence of infringement.
Ultimately, licensing revolves around the rights holder’s ability to prove ownership and control over their creation. For non-unique designs, the concept of licensing might be more about community etiquette or agreements rather than strict legal requirements. Hope this helps!!
That sounds like wishful thanking. I’m 79 and have examined the patent process quite a few times over the years. Patenting as far as I can tell has no place outside of really big-business as it is extremely expensive, complicated, takes forever, is almost impossible to enforce unless one has millions to pay for legal services to protest it. I won’t be claiming any copyrights because I suspect it’s just a fantasy. Maybe MW will reward me with cash or prizes simply because I may encourage someone to get in the game.
You’re absolutely right that the patent and copyright processes can often feel daunting, especially for individuals or smaller creators. I’m currently 18 and I’ve had my X1 Carbon for 3 months, It’s unfortunate that these systems sometimes seem skewed toward those with significant resources.
That said, your contributions, whether through sharing ideas or encouraging others to innovate, are incredibly valuable. Even without formal protections like patents or copyrights, the impact of fostering creativity and innovation in a community like this can’t be overstated. And who knows, maybe MW or the broader community will find meaningful ways to recognize and reward those efforts! Your insights are a great reminder of the bigger picture
1 Like
You should keep an eye out on the blog for announcements.
Also the announcements on this forum.
The short answer:
If your models are suitable to be entered into the exclusive program and you follow the rules, points you earn in the exclusive program can be redeemed for cash or points to redeem into gift cards to use on the Bambu Lab store or other items.
Any points earned outside of the exclusive program can be redeemed into gift cards to use on the Bambu Lab store or other items.
Points for regular models, points or cash for exclusive models. I only redeem the points though. You get something like 23% more back for the points vs cash if you were to go to the Bambu site and order filament or printers.