Low Ratings without description

Thanks, YMMD!
I never reported ratings and comments because the selectable reasons do not fit.

I have been struggling with these ā€œrating trollsā€ too, who can push candy colored buttons on an app, but they can’t read descriptions no matter how big and bold you point it out.

Now i reported one and it took less than 5 minutes and the 1 star rating was gone.

3 Likes

@MakerWorld i have been reporting several and you guys arent taking action any more, getting frustrating when you get ratings sabatoged over things out of our power

1 Like

There’s been a new flood lately. Everyone’s getting printers now that we are heading into winter.
We all learn along the way, but at some point I know I’ll have no patience left and I’ll need to stop posting here and on MW.
My worry is that new users like this, that do not deserve anger, will eventually trigger me and then I’ll feel bad.

image

or many others that don’t use the profile’s setting then give a 1 star rating because it didn’t work. :man_shrugging:

4 Likes

Loved the image description name :sweat_smile:

2 Likes

Please send the URL of this print profile to me. We will check it.

Just remember whoever is posting it could be a very young person and patience is required some times.:grin:

Did my son tell you to post this?!? Tell him this does not get him out of having to clean the litter box!
:wink:
And yeah I know… that’s why I said they do not deserve anger. But it can be grating sometimes.

1 Like

As a newcomer to 3D printing, I appreciate the work that creators invest in their models.
If I download a model, I have an interest in the model working in my use case, rating the usefulness is easy. It seems like rating a print profile that wasn’t configured for my specific printer or filament doesn’t appear to make sense. Also, designers have no control over my environment, maintenance or my stupidity. I can comment on design issues, but even that in many cases is my opinion. Creators in general are usually responsive, but clearly a lot of people don’t want to invest the time in rating a print. FYI I don’t rate everything that I print, when I do, I try to include an image.

I have a question about printing models, does the creator benefit from me printing the same object multiple times, is there a benefit to the creator if I rate each print process?

I think that rating the print profile is Bambu’s way of suggesting to make print profiles ā€œworkingā€ and for ā€œratingā€ model there’s likes (with no value to them except maybe algorithmic) and boosts (with a lot of value to them).

The print profiles are especially handy for bambu handy (pun) since there’s no way in the handy to configure slicing params. So users are left at the mercy of print profile creator.

That’s why I made couple suggestions to improve profile rating flow to account for that: Require user to troubleshoot before rating

I do recommend rating, especially when everything went well, that helps creators (especially those with very little or no ratings on their profiles)

AFAIK no, only the first counts.

AFAIK no, only the first counts (unless single object has multiple print profiles for eg addons, in which case rating each print profile for separate item does count)

darn i was hoping this was sincere and you would handle it, but here we are back to getting no help with stuff :frowning: thanks anyhow

I just checked this print profile. It’s indeed very easy to collapse during printing, and these several parts are all lacking sufficient adhesion area on the heated bed.

I suggest splitting the handle parts, which could make this model easy to print.


1 Like

If you clean your bed it wont fall i had over 250 others it didnt fall off on its also a 1 piece print, so one person cant clean their bed and i get rating abused for it. You guys are a real let down supporting designers

I think @Tanklet is correct in his assessment - based on the screenshots I can imagine that the print can fail even with clean bed and bambu filament. The problem is that for beginner it’s hard to convey the message and for designer to get it.

Why don’t you add a profile made as suggested by @Tanklet with a name suggesting that’s it’s multi-part and made easier to print for those who need it? Then if the one-star rating for ā€œdifficultā€ profile comes, you can point user to easier version and ask for the removal of rating for difficult one.

1 Like

because hundreds of others can print it no problem, just one turd that cant clean his bed says he cant do it and gave 1 star

lol you can’t argue against facts that is a poor positioning, sure it can print now and again, but it’s a roll of the dice

The way you dismiss perfectly valid suggestions tells a lot, and it’s not bambu not supporting its designers given that @Tanklet even went through the trouble of giving you examples on how to make it better

4 Likes

If hundreds of others can print it no problem, the one star rating from that one turd shouldn’t be an issue. So don’t worry about it.

That said, it is our responsibility as designers to create designs that are suitable for 3D printing and, in the case of MW, add print profiles that have a margin for error.

In this case both issues are not addressed IMO. Ideally a design would have as much bed contact surface as possible with as little support as possible. If that

3 Likes

His suggestion is not better, it has 4 solid points it touches the bed along with added supports. I have it angled for a reason and its a simple print the fact that hundreds have printed it with no issue should be evidence enough that it doesnt deserve a 1 star ratring along with the fact the person provided no proof whatsoever he even tried to print it. I have printed 20 of them myself ZERO failures but i clean my bed.

it is better, it looks like you don’t understand how, and that is part of the problem

you keep saying hundreds have printed, you have 116 makes, and quite a few highlights in the comments with issues, on which you are always defensive saying it’s bed adhesion or filament calibration Ā· sure those issues happens sometimes, but your profile is setting up for failure

you can argue all you want, i’ll not further discuss, you’re clearly a brilliant designer and printer and know better, in fact you shine so bright, that’s like it’s staring directly at the sun, which i can’t handle, so congratulations you made it to the ignore list :smiley:

1 Like

oh no im so hurt some random on the internet put me on her ignore list, whatever will i do… also i had it on other sites prior to making it exclusive with over 100 prints …

This is the photo you add as proof of printability:

image

With support around the way too tiny contact points

This is the profile that the poor chap tried to print and wasted his filament on:

No support and a teeny tiny contact patch that should hold up the lump of plastic on top while a hot-end is angrily trying to hash the infill as quickly as possible.

While both profiles are not ideal, the one with the one star rating that has no support to speak of has only 11 makes. (so not 250)

And then that poor chap that wasted his filament and time on a print profile that is just :poop: gets this abuse thrown his way as well:

Maybe you should follow your own advice?

5 Likes